Follows a community devastated by coal, starting with American Electric…
Small Is Beautiful: The Quest to Save the Valley of the Moon
- Description
- Reviews
- Citation
- Cataloging
- Transcript
In the heart of Sonoma Valley, in a region repeatedly scarred by catastrophic wildfire, a small rural community finds itself on the front lines of a battle that echoes far beyond its borders. Small Is Beautiful: The Quest to Save the Valley of the Moon is a gripping short documentary that chronicles the fight to stop a massive luxury development planned for the former Sonoma Developmental Center (SDC) — a state-owned property and former campus of a care facility for the disabled for almost a century — nestled between Eldridge and Glen Ellen at the base of Sonoma Mountain.
Long regarded as an ecological jewel, the SDC sits within a critical wildlife migration corridor connecting to the Mayacamas and beyond. Mountain lions, black-tailed deer, and thousands of species depend on this passage for survival and bio-diversity in the region. The property also lies squarely in a high-risk wildfire zone, surrounded by communities devastated by recent infernos. Yet despite these realities, the State of California has advanced a sweeping redevelopment plan: 990 housing units, 400,000 square feet of commercial space, and a luxury hotel and conference center — all proposed for a site served by narrow two-lane roads, constrained water resources, and limited evacuation capacity.
For residents, fire professionals, and environmental scientists, the proposal is not simply controversial — it is potentially catastrophic.
Through intimate interviews and on-the-ground footage, Small Is Beautiful: The Quest to Save the Valley of the Moon reveals how California’s aggressive housing mandates are fundamentally reshaping communities across the state. Featuring testimony from fire chiefs, environmental experts, housing advocates, and a former San Francisco Housing Commissioner turned whistleblower, the film challenges audiences to reconsider what “progress” truly means in an era of climate crisis. At once intimate and urgent, the film captures a community’s stand — and illuminates a pivotal debate about the future of California’s landscapes, laws, and lives.
"Small is Beautiful engages pressing questions at the intersection of wildfire risk and land-use planning in California, highlighting how development patterns and governance structures shape exposure in fire-prone regions. Focused and place-based, the film is visually compelling and thoughtfully constructed, effectively translating complex planning and environmental dynamics into a clear, accessible narrative." Emily Elizabeth Schlickman, Associate Professor of Landscape Architecture and Environmental Design, University of California-Davis
"Addresses a universal problem of high-density, upscale development...Resonates with viewers well beyond its home turf...Small is Beautiful's seemingly boundless appeal lies in its central theme: self-determination for local communities facing external mandates." Nate Seltenrich, Sonoma Magazine
"Luxury hotels, high-end housing units, and state mandates. Small elite cities are being plopped down in the middle of rural communities against their wishes. Who stands to benefit in today's high-stakes game of real estate development in California? Small is Beautiful is a sweeping indictment of how one local community and its ecology are being overrun by big money and misguided public policy in the Sonoma Valley under the guise of affordable housing." Bob Johnson, Professor of History, National University, Author, The Colonial Climate: Remaking Nature in San Diego
"Little film with a big story...gains worldwide acclaim." Daniel Johnson, The Press Democrat
"Small is Beautiful highlights a conflict that is neither small nor beautiful. It exposes how developers use California's affordable housing mandates as a 'Trojan Horse' to build luxury units in a critical wildlife corridor in Sonoma County. By ignoring the increasing wildfire risks of climate change, these projects threaten to turn rural landscapes into inescapable death traps for both current and future residents." Jonathan Fink, Professor of Geology, Portland State University, Founder, Cascadia Wildfire and Urban Smoke Working Group
Citation
Main credits
Scott, Carolyn M. (film director)
Scott, Carolyn M. (film producer)
Scott, Carolyn M. (screenwriter)
Miller, Carly (narrator)
Other credits
Cinematography, Gary D. Liess; editing, Denny Thomas, Carly Miller; music, Catherine Joy.
Distributor subjects
No distributor subjects provided.Keywords
[00:00:00.06]
[gentle piano music]
[00:00:12.09]
- [Narrator] In the realm of lore,
[00:00:14.03]
Sonoma Valley earned its
name Valley of the Moon
[00:00:17.05]
from Indigenous tales.
[00:00:20.02]
For the Indigenous peoples
who roamed its expanse,
[00:00:23.02]
the Sonoma Valley was
not merely earth and sky,
[00:00:26.03]
but a realm of profound
spiritual significance
[00:00:29.07]
deemed a sacred sanctuary.
[00:00:32.09]
Once home to the Miwok,
Pomo, and Wappo People,
[00:00:37.02]
stewards of this terrain
[00:00:38.07]
bestowed upon it names steeped
in their cultural tapestry.
[00:00:43.08]
Yet it was the literary
prowess of Jack London,
[00:00:46.08]
the iconic American novelist,
journalist, organic farmer,
[00:00:51.01]
and social activist, who
etched Valley of the Moon
[00:00:54.09]
into the annals of broader consciousness.
[00:00:59.01]
From the majestic redwoods
of Jack London State Park
[00:01:02.06]
to Sugarloaf Ridge's mythic beauty,
[00:01:05.02]
the Valley of the Moon's
serene oak woodlands
[00:01:08.02]
define this historic wine country region.
[00:01:11.07]
And those of us who call this place home
[00:01:14.01]
cherish it like no other.
[00:01:16.02]
[gentle piano music]
[00:01:20.06]
However, a shadow looms over us now,
[00:01:23.02]
and the battle to protect her has begun.
[00:01:27.02]
- [Firefighter] One moment
I need you. Jump home.
[00:01:30.00]
- [Dispatcher] Hi, medical dispatch.
[00:01:31.02]
- [911 Operator] County with a transfer
[00:01:32.01]
from a call from Kenwood.
[00:01:33.01]
- [Dispatcher] Thank you.
[00:01:34.04]
Hello?
- [Caller] Yes. Hello.
[00:01:35.08]
- [Dispatcher] What's the
address of the emergency?
[00:01:37.00]
- [Caller] Smoke.
[00:01:37.08]
- [Dispatcher] Alright,
we have lots of fire.
[00:01:38.07]
We have lots of fire and lots of wind.
[00:01:41.02]
If you see fire near
your building, evacuate.
[00:01:43.08]
- [Caller] We're on Egg Farm Road.
[00:01:45.05]
Do you have any information?
[00:01:46.06]
- [Dispatcher] No ma'am.
[00:01:47.05]
I can't help you, I'm sorry.
[00:01:48.06]
We're getting inundated
with too many fires.
[00:01:50.08]
- [Caller] We have a
90-year-old, we have two...
[00:01:53.01]
- [Dispatcher] Do you need somebody to--
[00:01:54.04]
Do you need somebody to help you evacuate?
[00:01:55.08]
- [Caller] Not me, it's our neighborhood.
[00:01:57.06]
I don't know...
[00:01:58.05]
- [Dispatcher] Okay, ma'am.
[00:01:59.04]
- [Caller] They're elderly.
[00:02:00.02]
- [Dispatcher] Alright,
we'll send what we can.
[00:02:01.08]
We have fire department on the way.
[00:02:03.05]
- [Caller] When you say
fires, is it around?...
[00:02:06.03]
- [Dispatcher] Ma'am, I
need to go. I'm sorry.
[00:02:07.04]
We have fires all over
the county, I need to go.
[00:02:09.06]
- [Caller] And no one's
gonna evacuate or tell us?
[00:02:11.07]
- [Dispatcher] Well, you
need to evacuate yourself.
[00:02:14.00]
Do it now.
- [Caller] Okay-
[00:02:15.04]
- [Dispatcher] We'll let 'em know.
[00:02:16.02]
Thank you, bye.
[00:02:19.07]
[gentle piano music]
[00:02:32.07]
- [Narrator] Recently,
the state of California
[00:02:35.00]
decided to sell the property
[00:02:36.06]
formerly known as the
Sonoma Developmental Center,
[00:02:40.02]
a facility that provided
services to individuals
[00:02:43.02]
with disabilities for nearly a century.
[00:02:46.03]
Subsequently, the state
engaged a developer
[00:02:48.09]
to formulate a plan for the site.
[00:02:52.03]
Their proposal?
[00:02:54.01]
To transform a rural
community into urban sprawl.
[00:02:58.03]
The development plan includes allocating
[00:03:00.06]
approximately 180 acres
of what's commonly known
[00:03:04.08]
as the SDC campus to
accommodate a luxury resort
[00:03:09.04]
with hundreds of upscale homes.
[00:03:12.00]
In essence, this proposal
amounts to dropping a small city
[00:03:16.01]
into a wildlife sanctuary and
rural region of Sonoma Valley.
[00:03:20.08]
[gentle piano music]
[00:03:25.02]
- The Sonoma supervisors approved a plan
[00:03:28.05]
that would have put 650
homes on this property,
[00:03:33.09]
and then the developer
comes back and says,
[00:03:36.05]
"Well, that 650's not enough.
[00:03:38.04]
I can't make enough money
if we only allow 650."
[00:03:43.05]
So he's now proposing as
many as a thousand homes
[00:03:47.08]
and a high-end resort hotel,
[00:03:50.07]
and turning it into a tourist attraction
[00:03:53.00]
for people that could afford them.
[00:03:55.00]
It could not be in a worse location.
[00:03:58.02]
It ruins a pristine, beautiful valley.
[00:04:01.01]
[gentle piano music]
[00:04:05.01]
- [Judith] So if there
was a fire, Elizabeth,
[00:04:08.03]
and we had all these developments
and that many more cars,
[00:04:12.07]
what's your concern?
[00:04:14.01]
- Oh, I would be utterly panicked.
[00:04:16.06]
I don't know what I would do.
[00:04:18.04]
Knowing that the stories that I've seen
[00:04:20.06]
and the deaths that occurred in Paradise,
[00:04:23.04]
I mean people would die,
there's no question,
[00:04:26.05]
if a fire replicated
anything close to 2017.
[00:04:31.05]
Our land was ablaze.
[00:04:33.06]
Our beautiful home was,
it just vanished.
[00:04:36.03]
I mean, we looked at the result
[00:04:37.08]
after we got back to our property
[00:04:40.00]
and it was nothing but ash.
[00:04:41.02]
It must have gone in five seconds.
[00:04:43.01]
So people will die, for sure.
[00:04:46.08]
Everything's unconscionable.
[00:04:48.06]
- [Judith] About this.
- Yeah.
[00:04:50.06]
- It has to do with climate change.
[00:04:51.06]
It has to do with water filtration,
[00:04:53.04]
it has to do with water
setbacks from the creeks.
[00:04:55.03]
It has to do with wildlife.
[00:04:56.08]
It has to do with fire
and fire evacuation.
[00:04:59.07]
All of these things are related
to developing this property.
[00:05:06.03]
- To me, Sonoma Development
Center is a gorgeous spot.
[00:05:11.00]
It's beautiful, but it's
an incredible resource
[00:05:13.09]
for all of Sonoma Valley.
[00:05:15.05]
It is state land, it's our land.
[00:05:18.07]
It doesn't belong to a developer.
[00:05:21.00]
It belongs to all the
people of Sonoma Valley.
[00:05:23.06]
And the whole notion that
we should give it away
[00:05:26.04]
to some developer to make
money was just anathema to me.
[00:05:30.05]
Once it's gone, it's gone forever.
[00:05:33.00]
The state would never buy that land back
[00:05:35.02]
and turn it into a park.
[00:05:36.06]
It's gone.
[00:05:38.02]
The people who actually
came up with the plan
[00:05:41.03]
also then wrote the
environmental impact report.
[00:05:44.01]
The people who are experts in this,
[00:05:46.09]
many of them use the phrase,
[00:05:49.00]
"This environmental impact report
[00:05:51.02]
looks like it was written in
order to bring on a lawsuit."
[00:05:54.05]
It's so badly done.
[00:05:57.01]
They're required by law
[00:05:58.04]
to address the various
complaints and issues
[00:06:01.07]
that local people bring up as
part of the review process.
[00:06:05.00]
Came back with the final
environmental impact report,
[00:06:08.04]
there were thousands of pages, literally,
[00:06:10.07]
where they're answering
questions and issues.
[00:06:13.04]
In the vast bulk of those
cases the answer was,
[00:06:16.02]
"We've looked at it and
don't think it's a problem."
[00:06:19.06]
And the terminology for that
is it's self-mitigating,
[00:06:23.00]
meaning, "Maybe we'll figure
it out when we build."
[00:06:25.09]
[gentle orchestral music]
[00:06:29.04]
- The compounding factors is
[00:06:30.08]
the county is proving
multiple large developments
[00:06:35.01]
with no cumulative impact analysis.
[00:06:37.01]
So, the SDC is only one.
[00:06:39.06]
We have the Hanna Housing Development,
[00:06:41.08]
we have the Kenwood Inn
with the new hotel, Elnoka.
[00:06:45.01]
There's a number of additional projects
[00:06:47.07]
that are being planned.
[00:06:49.02]
The county is also denying expenditures
[00:06:52.06]
to improve the roads that
we rely on for evacuation,
[00:06:57.01]
and they're using big data traffic model
[00:07:00.01]
that two consulting firms
showed substantial evidence
[00:07:04.04]
that that traffic model
[00:07:06.04]
significantly underestimates
the number of vehicles
[00:07:10.03]
that will be on these evacuation routes.
[00:07:13.08]
- If I have a restaurant,
and I chain the doors shut
[00:07:17.06]
where people can't get out,
I'll be held criminally liable.
[00:07:22.00]
What's the difference about
building a bunch of homes
[00:07:24.07]
and giving you one way out?
[00:07:26.04]
It ain't the smartest plan in the book.
[00:07:29.03]
- [Narrator] The chosen
developer's proposal
[00:07:31.04]
includes the erection
of 400,000 square feet
[00:07:34.03]
of commercial space adorned
with a luxury resort hotel
[00:07:38.01]
and conference center
alongside a sprawling array
[00:07:41.05]
of 930 residential units.
[00:07:45.07]
However, a mere fraction, only 12%,
[00:07:48.08]
are earmarked for affordable housing.
[00:07:52.01]
- Developers build houses to make money.
[00:07:55.02]
They're not in the business
of creating affordable units.
[00:07:58.04]
The affordable units they have to create
[00:08:00.03]
are mandated by law.
[00:08:01.07]
Luxury units account for 85, 90,
[00:08:05.02]
95% of the housing productions
actually would be built.
[00:08:08.09]
And that's not affordable
[00:08:10.05]
to the person that makes $50,000 a year
[00:08:12.09]
or $70,000 or even $150,000.
[00:08:17.08]
- [Narrator] Central to our concern
[00:08:19.04]
is the proposed location
of this urban monolith
[00:08:22.07]
and its opulent lodgings,
[00:08:24.08]
strategically placed at the crossroads
[00:08:27.00]
of a vital wildlife corridor.
[00:08:30.09]
This corridor, a lifeline
for the migration of animals
[00:08:34.04]
to the Mayacamas Mountains,
[00:08:36.03]
stands imperiled by the development.
[00:08:38.06]
[gentle instrumental music]
[00:08:41.07]
Its disruption not only endangers
[00:08:43.09]
the delicate balance
of our native habitat,
[00:08:46.06]
but also fractures the intricate web
[00:08:48.09]
of the valley's ecosystem,
[00:08:51.00]
interrupting natural mating patterns
[00:08:53.04]
and endangering biodiversity.
[00:08:55.06]
[music continues]
[00:08:58.05]
- The county is not in
compliance with the law.
[00:09:01.03]
They're not in compliance
with the environmental laws,
[00:09:05.07]
the land use laws,
[00:09:07.02]
and even the state laws
around fire safe evacuations.
[00:09:12.02]
By law, under the state
environmental laws,
[00:09:16.03]
the county must look at
these known projects.
[00:09:20.05]
The county knows that these
projects are in the pipeline
[00:09:23.09]
and do a cumulative impact analysis.
[00:09:26.04]
Well, if the current
residents and tourists
[00:09:31.04]
can't get out on these
over-capacity roads,
[00:09:35.06]
how are the people from the
SDC plus Hanna, plus Kenwood,
[00:09:41.04]
how are we going to accommodate them?
[00:09:47.00]
The worst case scenario might be
[00:09:49.00]
if a fire came over Sonoma Mountain.
[00:09:52.05]
That area has not burned
in many, many years.
[00:09:56.09]
And if a very fast moving fire
[00:09:59.07]
comes into the Sonoma Development Center--
[00:10:03.02]
It's a small city
[00:10:05.04]
that we're talking about plopping
[00:10:06.07]
in the middle of a rural
area right next to a mountain
[00:10:10.05]
and beautiful open space.
[00:10:13.00]
That fire moving so fast
[00:10:16.01]
could overwhelm the community
[00:10:17.08]
before they have a chance to get out.
[00:10:20.07]
- I've been coming up to
Sonoma since the '60s.
[00:10:24.02]
Even my dad, he was a San
Francisco firefighter,
[00:10:26.00]
come up years ago for the 1963 fire,
[00:10:28.07]
which was on that side of the valley.
[00:10:30.00]
And since then, I know for a fact
[00:10:32.01]
it's been hit with sudden oak disease.
[00:10:34.00]
So, there's a lot of dead
and dying trees up there.
[00:10:37.07]
- I really dove into the draft EIR
[00:10:40.04]
for the Springs Specific Plan,
[00:10:42.05]
which had evacuation issues
and challenges within it.
[00:10:46.05]
I also got to read the SDC report, so.
[00:10:49.07]
- [Judith] And what did you think of them?
[00:10:52.05]
- I think it's a joke.
[00:10:54.01]
It's not...it's not real.
[00:10:56.01]
- [Judith] Why?
[00:10:57.09]
Because, it's gonna take
more than a minute and a half
[00:11:00.08]
or two minutes to evacuate people.
[00:11:03.09]
The evacuation study, or in
different documents you read,
[00:11:07.08]
they encourage people
to take just one car.
[00:11:11.08]
Well, that's not the reality.
[00:11:13.01]
When somebody's fleeing a fire
[00:11:15.04]
and wondering if their
home's gonna be there
[00:11:17.05]
when they get back,
[00:11:20.00]
they take as many cars as they can
[00:11:22.05]
'cause that's maybe
all they're gonna have.
[00:11:25.04]
It's not uncommon to have
maybe one of those vehicles
[00:11:28.07]
with just a quarter tank of gas,
[00:11:30.03]
which is problematic when
you're sitting in traffic
[00:11:32.00]
for hours on end.
[00:11:33.05]
Sonoma has six ways in
and out of this valley.
[00:11:36.09]
And that day, in 2017,
[00:11:40.05]
five of those six routes were on fire.
[00:11:42.09]
[gentle piano music]
[00:11:47.02]
- You're asking for disaster,
putting all those in.
[00:11:49.07]
As it is now,
[00:11:51.02]
trying to get people
outta here in just the
[00:11:53.04]
neighborhoods that are
around here now is huge.
[00:11:56.04]
And now you're gonna add
all these more people.
[00:12:00.05]
Again, I mean, you wouldn't
do it in a building.
[00:12:02.07]
You look at any of these buildings here
[00:12:04.00]
or any building you go into.
[00:12:05.04]
I do inspections,
[00:12:06.09]
and every building has an
occupancy load on that building.
[00:12:11.06]
You would think they
would have occupancy loads
[00:12:13.01]
for neighborhoods.
[00:12:14.02]
[gentle piano music]
[wind gusting]
[00:12:17.05]
- A good portion of the
people who died in Paradise,
[00:12:21.00]
the 87 people who died, over
80% were over the age of 65.
[00:12:26.02]
So they either could not
get out of their home,
[00:12:29.03]
or they were found on their property.
[00:12:32.03]
So, they may have been a younger person
[00:12:34.09]
who stayed home to defend their house.
[00:12:37.05]
And then, as we know,
[00:12:39.01]
10 or more were killed in their vehicles
[00:12:42.04]
trying to race ahead of the fire.
[00:12:45.09]
Now we have the same kind of
situation in Sonoma County.
[00:12:50.02]
This is what happened
during the Glass Fire.
[00:12:52.03]
The orderly evacuation plan
that Sonoma County has in place
[00:12:57.06]
assumed that they would be able to say,
[00:12:59.06]
"Okay, it's time for zone two to evacuate.
[00:13:02.06]
Now let's get zone three
heading on down the highway."
[00:13:06.08]
And the fire was moving so fast
[00:13:10.05]
that there was only an hour.
[00:13:12.07]
The fire was on people's doorsteps,
[00:13:15.08]
and so everybody evacuated
at the same time.
[00:13:19.05]
And Highway 12 and Highway 121 and 116
[00:13:23.03]
were basically in gridlock.
[00:13:25.01]
It was a parking lot.
[00:13:27.03]
It's a miracle nobody was killed.
[00:13:31.08]
- [Narrator] The proposed development
[00:13:33.01]
poses a significant risk to
our community's infrastructure.
[00:13:37.06]
Water remains an ongoing critical issue,
[00:13:40.05]
as does traffic on our already
narrow two-lane rural roads.
[00:13:45.06]
And the SDC development
[00:13:47.03]
is projected to increase traffic
by an alarming 40 to 70%.
[00:13:52.00]
[tense instrumental music]
[00:13:53.08]
A contentious environmental impact report,
[00:13:56.06]
rife with omissions, regarding
critical environmental
[00:14:00.01]
and safety concerns is
paving the way for peril
[00:14:03.05]
and the degradation of our
community's quality of life.
[00:14:09.01]
The rampant development of
this delicate pastoral valley
[00:14:13.01]
threatens irreversible consequences
[00:14:15.05]
and potentially catastrophic outcomes.
[00:14:20.00]
- The wildlife corridor is
a huge wildlife corridor.
[00:14:24.04]
It extends from the ocean all the way east
[00:14:28.01]
to the land around Lake Berryessa.
[00:14:32.08]
It's huge.
[00:14:34.07]
Thousands of species go back and forth.
[00:14:36.07]
But it all comes down to
a tiny little pinch point
[00:14:39.03]
of about a mile to two miles
[00:14:41.03]
in the Sonoma Developmental Center.
[00:14:43.09]
And while this center was in use
[00:14:47.05]
there were no fences.
[00:14:49.00]
At night, the lights were basically out.
[00:14:51.03]
It was very porous for
animals to go through
[00:14:53.05]
even though there was actually
a lot of people there,
[00:14:56.01]
but no one was out at night,
[00:14:57.02]
in general the lights were off.
[00:14:59.04]
Now there's gonna be lights, fences, pets,
[00:15:05.05]
noise all night.
[00:15:08.00]
It's just killing that wildlife corridor.
[00:15:10.00]
That was basically ignored, also.
[00:15:12.04]
[somber instrumental music]
[00:15:16.07]
- Before this land was
stolen from the Coast Miwok,
[00:15:21.07]
most of Sonoma Valley
[00:15:24.08]
would have been wetlands.
[00:15:26.09]
The creeks all meandered,
[00:15:28.04]
and there were beavers damning them up.
[00:15:30.03]
We didn't have these
narrow creeks with steep,
[00:15:35.03]
incised sides that go relatively straight.
[00:15:37.06]
The creeks went this way and that way
[00:15:38.09]
and then it was a beaver dam,
[00:15:40.02]
and then eventually another beaver dam
[00:15:42.09]
and another beaver dam.
[00:15:44.05]
You still have at the very
bottom of Sonoma Creek watershed,
[00:15:48.07]
there are still the saltwater wetlands.
[00:15:52.00]
But almost all of the
freshwater wetlands are gone,
[00:15:56.01]
except on this property.
[00:15:57.06]
[gentle instrumental music]
[00:16:02.02]
In California state parks,
[00:16:04.00]
they don't allow dogs
on most of the trails
[00:16:06.08]
because studies have shown
[00:16:08.06]
just a couple of dogs coming through
[00:16:10.07]
makes the trail smell like predators,
[00:16:14.01]
and that affects the behavior
of much of the wildlife.
[00:16:18.00]
The wildlife will avoid those areas.
[00:16:20.04]
If you fill an area with people's yards,
[00:16:24.05]
and there are house cats going around
[00:16:26.00]
killing the small wildlife
[00:16:28.02]
and there are dogs running around
[00:16:30.05]
and there are vehicles
running the salamanders over
[00:16:35.02]
and there is light
shining out the windows,
[00:16:37.08]
it has serious ecological effects.
[00:16:41.05]
And the way that we tend to
build is we tend to sprawl.
[00:16:45.05]
These buildings right here
[00:16:47.02]
would be where the hotel is planned,
[00:16:49.08]
and there is a creek right here.
[00:16:53.01]
That creek is a habitat corridor
[00:16:56.01]
that wildlife uses all the time.
[00:16:57.08]
We're talking maybe 50 feet
[00:17:00.02]
between the water and the buildings,
[00:17:03.01]
and that's a bad idea.
[00:17:07.06]
- [Narrator] It is also important to note
[00:17:09.03]
that endangered Chinook salmon
[00:17:11.07]
swim through the SDC
property in Sonoma Creek
[00:17:14.09]
to spawn further upstream at
Sugarloaf Ridge State Park.
[00:17:21.00]
Exacerbating the urban sprawl situation,
[00:17:23.07]
several other out-of-scale
projects are planned
[00:17:26.07]
within a few miles of the SDC.
[00:17:29.04]
The Hanna Development has the
exact same development plan
[00:17:32.04]
as the SDC, including a luxury hotel
[00:17:35.05]
and a massive residential
and commercial project.
[00:17:40.05]
Then there is the Oakmont Elnoka
project, the Kenwood Ranch,
[00:17:44.06]
the Verano Hotel, and the
new housing development
[00:17:47.06]
in Boyes Hot Springs.
[00:17:49.05]
[somber instrumental music]
[00:17:52.09]
These developments will add
thousands of additional cars
[00:17:56.02]
to already overwhelmed rural roads.
[00:18:00.05]
Over the past seven years,
[00:18:02.02]
both state and county authorities
[00:18:04.04]
were required to get community involvement
[00:18:06.08]
in determining the fate of the land.
[00:18:11.02]
In response, thousands of
Sonoma Valley residents
[00:18:14.02]
dedicated themselves
to the lengthy process.
[00:18:19.01]
Through numerous meetings, testimonies,
[00:18:21.01]
and exhaustive work on development plans.
[00:18:23.07]
The community diligently deliberated
[00:18:25.08]
on how the land should be utilized.
[00:18:29.06]
However, it became evident
[00:18:31.00]
that the county's hands
were tied by the mandates,
[00:18:33.07]
and essentially they have no power.
[00:18:37.00]
Counties across the state of California
[00:18:38.09]
are being fined huge penalties
[00:18:41.01]
for not being able to comply
[00:18:42.06]
with the number of units
required by the state mandates.
[00:18:46.07]
- The control is in the developer camp,
[00:18:49.01]
not in the public sphere.
[00:18:51.07]
They actually are writing the legislation.
[00:18:53.06]
They literally write the law
[00:18:55.08]
and hand it to the senator or
the assembly person and say,
[00:18:59.00]
"We'd like for you to pass this."
[00:19:01.01]
You don't understand what's gonna happen
[00:19:02.06]
literally next door to you
until the bulldozer comes
[00:19:05.03]
and porta potty gets put out front.
[00:19:08.02]
- [Narrator] This experience
leads one to infer,
[00:19:11.00]
whether justly or not,
[00:19:12.07]
that the community's
engagement was manipulated
[00:19:14.07]
to prevent or preemptively quash
[00:19:17.07]
any organized public opposition
[00:19:19.08]
to simply selling the land
to the highest bidder.
[00:19:23.00]
Precisely what is occurring.
[00:19:25.00]
[gentle piano music]
[00:19:28.07]
- People in Glen Allen live in Glen Allen
[00:19:31.02]
because Glen Allen is Glen Allen.
[00:19:33.08]
It's a small little town.
[00:19:36.00]
It's got a little bar
and a restaurant there,
[00:19:38.01]
and it's got a little bakery, a store.
[00:19:40.08]
It's rural, it's simple.
[00:19:43.01]
Everyone knows everyone.
[00:19:44.06]
And this is gonna change all that.
[00:19:48.03]
The phrase "follow the money,"
[00:19:50.02]
it applies here a hundred percent.
[00:19:52.08]
These developers are gonna get rich
[00:19:55.00]
and the politicians will follow suit.
[00:19:58.06]
I've never met a poor developer,
[00:20:01.02]
nor have I met a poor politician.
[00:20:03.03]
And they want this project to go through
[00:20:06.09]
even though I think a majority
of the people in this valley,
[00:20:09.09]
or at least a majority
of the people in the area
[00:20:12.04]
that's going to be built in,
don't want this.
[00:20:15.02]
There's a lot of people.
[00:20:16.02]
I'm happy to tell you
that I think more people
[00:20:18.03]
are aware of what the impact will be,
[00:20:21.01]
and they're becoming involved
with trying to stop this.
[00:20:25.08]
You gotta let these politicians know
[00:20:27.06]
that you're going against
the will of the people here.
[00:20:31.04]
Y'know, I was a fireman for a long time.
[00:20:33.09]
You get a fire of the
magnitude we had in the past,
[00:20:37.01]
and the traffic and the egress,
[00:20:39.09]
it's just not gonna happen.
[00:20:42.04]
You're gonna see people die,
[00:20:44.03]
and you're gonna see a lot of homes lost.
[00:20:46.07]
[tense instrumental music]
[00:20:50.09]
- [Narrator] What is important to note
[00:20:52.05]
is that numerous laws exist
to prevent urban sprawl
[00:20:56.01]
encroaching into green
belts and open-space buffers
[00:20:59.03]
between urban centers.
[00:21:01.04]
It's evident that both
the state and county
[00:21:04.03]
are acting in flagrant disregard
of their professed climate
[00:21:08.01]
and environmental commitments.
[00:21:10.02]
[somber instrumental music]
[wind gusting]
[00:21:13.02]
This raises the fundamental question,
[00:21:16.00]
why is public land funded
by taxpayers' money
[00:21:19.09]
being allowed to be privatized
[00:21:22.01]
and commodified without public consent?
[00:21:27.05]
Once upon a time,
[00:21:28.08]
there was a fellow who
happened to see a baby
[00:21:30.09]
going down the river.
[00:21:33.01]
He rescued the little infant
only to see two, three,
[00:21:36.09]
and dozens more going down the river.
[00:21:41.01]
He enlisted the help of
others in his community.
[00:21:44.09]
He made a big net, he built a bridge.
[00:21:49.07]
And finally, a wise man said to him,
[00:21:52.05]
"Why don't you go up the river
[00:21:54.02]
and see who is throwing them in?"
[00:21:57.00]
If you follow the river up
to the development bonanza
[00:22:00.01]
and urban sprawl that is
unfolding in California
[00:22:03.04]
and here in the Valley of the Moon,
[00:22:05.06]
you will find the state of
California's housing mandates
[00:22:08.09]
and high-end developers
whose only objective
[00:22:12.00]
is to maximize profits.
[00:22:16.09]
While these mandates claim to
promote affordable housing,
[00:22:20.02]
the vast majority of these new homes,
[00:22:22.07]
88% or more, are luxury upscale housing,
[00:22:26.07]
and remain far from affordable
for the average citizen.
[00:22:30.06]
In light of these disparities,
it begs the question,
[00:22:33.09]
who truly stands to benefit
from this arrangement?
[00:22:37.00]
[somber instrumental music]
[00:22:45.06]
[gentle piano music]
[00:23:05.03]
[music continues]
[00:23:33.01]
[music continues]
[00:24:02.02]
[gentle piano music]
[00:24:30.07]
[music continues]
[00:24:34.00]
Distributor: Bullfrog Films
Length: 25 minutes
Date: 2025
Genre: Expository
Language: English
Grade: 7-12, College, Adults
Closed Captioning: Available
Existing customers, please log in to view this film.
New to Docuseek? Register to request a quote.
Related Films
A Radical Thread
A back-to-the-land community fights off corporate Goliaths intent on environmental…