She Even Chewed Tobacco
- Description
- Reviews
- Citation
- Cataloging
- Transcript
The Gold Rush. A new frontier. Nineteenth century California offered women the opportunity to pioneer new roles for themselves. Meet Babe Bean, the "trouser puzzle" who escaped the hot glare of tabloid headlines by disguising herself as Jack Garland and serving in the Spanish American War. Or Jeanne Bonnet, who scored a record of 22+ arrests for wearing male attire, went to prison for her indiscretions and later organized a group of prostitutes into a shoplifting ring!
"A fascinating eye-opening tribute to the stamina and chutzpah of some of yesterday's most notable pariahs!" —The Advocate
Credits and citation support are not available for this title yet.
A MARC record for this title is not available yet.
Distributor subjects
No distributor subjects provided.Keywords
00:08.939 --> 00:09.939
Yeah.
00:46.240 --> 00:48.159
19th century America.
00:49.150 --> 00:50.849
The Victorian age.
00:52.599 --> 00:54.369
The industrial age.
00:56.360 --> 00:58.180
The era of the frontier.
01:00.729 --> 01:04.650
What was life like for American women in the
19th century?
01:06.980 --> 01:09.550
At first glance, the answer seemed simple.
01:10.519 --> 01:14.519
White middle-class women led domestic, pious
lives.
01:15.680 --> 01:18.239
Filled with housework and childbearing.
01:19.500 --> 01:23.080
Devoid of sexual or political interests.
01:24.779 --> 01:26.410
They knew their place.
01:27.239 --> 01:31.819
In the home, creating a comfortable refuge for
men.
01:32.800 --> 01:34.230
Who knew their place.
01:35.480 --> 01:40.550
Seeking fame and fortune in the public world of
paid labor or politics.
01:42.019 --> 01:44.860
Abundant images recall these stereotypes.
01:46.529 --> 01:48.000
When men were men.
01:48.760 --> 01:50.669
And women were women.
01:52.940 --> 01:59.650
And they suggest the relative freedom that most
white men enjoyed in contrast to the
01:59.650 --> 02:05.919
constraints placed on women's lives by laws,
custom, and clothing,
02:06.449 --> 02:12.089
but this first glance omits so much of our
history for some women.
02:13.580 --> 02:17.660
Like black slaves who worked alongside men.
02:18.960 --> 02:25.880
Others, like immigrants from Europe and Asia,
worked for low wages as
02:25.880 --> 02:28.119
domestics or factory operatives.
02:29.410 --> 02:33.320
And many middle-class white women left their
domestic world.
02:34.479 --> 02:36.679
They participated in reform efforts.
02:37.490 --> 02:40.440
And founded the early women's rights movement.
02:41.850 --> 02:48.160
Demanding equality with men in work, marriage,
and citizenship.
02:51.119 --> 02:57.990
Another small but significant group of American
women rejected the limitations of the female
02:57.990 --> 03:02.229
sphere and claimed the privileges enjoyed by
men.
03:03.089 --> 03:08.139
They worked for men's wages, courted and
married the women they loved,
03:08.630 --> 03:09.630
and even voted.
03:11.179 --> 03:17.490
They did so by adopting men's clothing, hiding
their female identities from most of the world,
03:17.940 --> 03:19.300
and passing as men.
03:20.449 --> 03:24.160
Since biblical times, some women have attempted
to pass as men,
03:24.649 --> 03:27.850
and they have been severely punished if
discovered.
03:28.940 --> 03:31.039
And yet, they took this risk.
03:31.289 --> 03:36.839
They passed to become soldiers or sailors, like
Mary Read and Anne Bonny,
03:37.089 --> 03:39.759
who sailed on pirate ships in the 18th century.
03:40.729 --> 03:43.490
Or they sought careers as doctors.
03:45.479 --> 03:48.800
Or escape from unhappy marriages.
03:50.630 --> 03:56.270
Were some of these women lesbians?
Although the term lesbian would not be used
03:56.270 --> 04:02.160
until the 20th century, many women did pass in
order to pursue the women they loved.
04:04.289 --> 04:11.080
In 19th century America, passing women tried to
explain in words or deeds why they
04:11.080 --> 04:13.750
chose their masquerade.
04:14.119 --> 04:19.269
Do you blame me for wanting to be a man free to
live life in a man-made world?
04:19.720 --> 04:21.760
So wrote Cora Anderson.
04:23.260 --> 04:30.040
An American Indian woman who passed as Ralph
Kerwinio. In the future centuries,
04:30.290 --> 04:36.140
it is probable that woman will be the owner of
her own body and the custodian of her own soul.
04:37.010 --> 04:43.059
But the well cared for woman now is a parasite,
and the woman who must work is a slave.
04:44.339 --> 04:49.059
Do you blame me for hating to again resume a
woman's clothing and just belong?
04:49.739 --> 04:54.260
Is it any wonder that I determined to become a
member of the privileged sex,
04:54.369 --> 05:00.970
if possible?
Cora Anderson or Ralph Carwinio twice married
05:00.970 --> 05:07.089
women.
Marie White on the left and a Dorothy Klinowski
05:07.089 --> 05:12.410
on the right.
I made up my mind to dress in men's attire to
05:12.410 --> 05:17.279
seek labor as I was used to men's work and only
get $1 per week,
05:17.570 --> 05:21.570
and I was capable of doing men's work and
getting men's wages.
05:21.649 --> 05:24.890
I resolved to try to get work away among
strangers.
05:25.869 --> 05:32.420
So spoke Lucy Anne Lobdell, who lived together
with another woman as husband and wife for over
05:32.420 --> 05:37.940
a decade.
When I was about 20 I decided that I was almost
05:37.940 --> 05:39.329
at the end of my rope.
05:39.779 --> 05:43.850
I had no money, and a woman's wages were not
enough to keep me alive.
05:44.640 --> 05:50.420
I looked around and saw men getting more money
and more work and more money for the same kind
05:50.420 --> 05:53.540
of work.
I decided to become a man.
05:53.829 --> 05:54.980
It was simple.
05:55.549 --> 05:58.779
I just put on men's clothing and applied for a
man's job.
05:59.070 --> 06:03.510
I got it and got good money for the times, so I
stuck to it.
06:04.269 --> 06:11.059
The words of Charles Warner, who masqueraded as
a man in upstate New York for over
06:11.059 --> 06:12.369
60 years.
06:14.260 --> 06:19.779
These passing women enjoyed the economic and
sexual privileges reserved for men.
06:20.609 --> 06:22.369
They could also vote.
06:23.369 --> 06:29.339
In New York City, Murray Hall, a woman who
passed as a man for 25 years,
06:29.869 --> 06:36.390
became an influential politician in the Tammany
Hall Democratic machine during the 1880s and
06:36.390 --> 06:37.579
1890s.
06:38.589 --> 06:40.619
Twice she married other women.
06:43.040 --> 06:47.220
Whatever their motives for passing, to earn a
decent wage,
06:47.470 --> 06:54.359
to marry women, or to enjoy political rights,
all passing women were in constant danger
06:54.359 --> 07:00.390
of exposure, arrest, and incarceration in a
jail or insane asylum.
07:01.910 --> 07:08.299
To avoid these risks, women who chose to live
as men had to perfect their masquerade.
07:09.279 --> 07:11.440
They had to be physically strong.
07:12.399 --> 07:14.040
Confident on the streets.
07:15.279 --> 07:18.589
And know how to flirt with women.
07:19.929 --> 07:22.440
For some women, this came easily.
07:23.260 --> 07:25.220
Others learned these skills gradually.
07:26.380 --> 07:33.369
A newspaper account of Bill, a Missouri laborer
who became local secretary of the
07:33.369 --> 07:38.809
International Brotherhood of Boilermakers,
typified the successful passing woman.
07:39.790 --> 07:40.910
She drank.
07:41.220 --> 07:44.529
She swore, she courted girls.
07:44.850 --> 07:47.040
She worked as hard as her fellows.
07:47.799 --> 07:49.579
She fished and camped.
07:50.179 --> 07:53.390
She even chewed tobacco.
08:03.200 --> 08:09.239
American migrants and foreign immigrants poured
into the Western states during the 19th century.
08:10.779 --> 08:16.290
Displacing or exterminating Native Americans
and, in California and the Southwest,
08:16.940 --> 08:20.489
seizing the lands of earlier Spanish and
Mexican settlers.
08:21.570 --> 08:24.000
Few women ventured to the West on their own.
08:24.929 --> 08:29.690
Usually families migrated together or single
men sought a quick fortune.
08:31.100 --> 08:35.940
Or a new start in life in the mining and cattle
towns of the frontier.
08:37.809 --> 08:41.200
Yet some women did strike out on their own in
the West.
08:42.450 --> 08:44.330
They traveled or worked alone.
08:45.080 --> 08:48.109
And, in some cases, they passed as men.
08:48.820 --> 08:54.070
In San Francisco, their stories were recorded
in numerous newspaper accounts.
08:55.200 --> 09:01.140
In 1847, San Francisco was a quiet village of
300 inhabitants,
09:01.630 --> 09:06.659
but the following year, the discovery of gold
created a boom town.
09:07.780 --> 09:13.489
By 1850, over 30,000 migrants swelled the
population.
09:14.580 --> 09:18.010
The few women on the streets included
merchants' wives.
09:19.059 --> 09:20.179
Prostitutes.
09:21.070 --> 09:23.359
And some passing women.
09:24.349 --> 09:29.849
In 1852, for instance, police arrested
Charlotte Arnold,
09:30.260 --> 09:33.969
a dressmaker, for disorderly conduct.
09:34.380 --> 09:37.489
She's a masculine species of the feminine
gender.
09:38.309 --> 09:39.340
Reporters claimed.
09:40.309 --> 09:47.090
In the courtroom, a judge instructed her to
behave with that propriety
09:47.090 --> 09:48.820
characteristic of your sex.
09:49.770 --> 09:55.700
San Francisco newspapers called another passing
woman a freak of fancy.
09:56.609 --> 10:00.760
And recognized the political significance of
her act.
10:01.280 --> 10:06.559
Our municipal laws have affixed a penalty to
this manner of deceiving the opposite sex.
10:07.510 --> 10:12.809
Our city laws have little regard for the
Bill of Rights adopted by the Women's
10:12.809 --> 10:14.830
Convention in the Atlantic states.
10:16.080 --> 10:22.080
But the laws could not prevent San Francisco
women from wearing men's clothing.
10:23.270 --> 10:30.219
In the 1850s, the well-known Lily
Hitchcockoitte visited night spots dressed in
10:30.219 --> 10:31.270
male attire.
10:31.979 --> 10:34.979
But she avoided arrest because she was wealthy.
10:37.419 --> 10:42.049
Charlie Parkhurst, a famous Wells Fargo
stagecoach driver,
10:42.659 --> 10:47.669
worked as a man for over 20 years and voted as
well.
10:49.070 --> 10:55.950
Louisa Matson was arrested near San Jose in
1895 for passing as businessman
10:55.950 --> 10:57.200
Milton Matson.
10:58.020 --> 11:02.510
She secretly moved to San Francisco and became
SB Matson,
11:02.880 --> 11:06.200
a man who worked in the San Francisco Public
Library.
11:07.000 --> 11:11.159
For years she courted a schoolteacher named
Helen Fairweather.
11:12.950 --> 11:19.450
Countless other women adopted male attire,
passed as men in order to earn a living,
11:19.989 --> 11:21.500
and loved other women.
11:22.849 --> 11:27.520
Two of their lives were especially well
documented in the newspapers.
11:27.890 --> 11:33.599
Jeannie Bonnet, who held the record for the
most arrests for wearing men's clothing.
11:34.940 --> 11:36.809
And Babe Bean.
11:37.669 --> 11:41.849
The trouser puzzle of Stockton, California.
11:54.729 --> 12:00.719
Jean Bonnet, or Jeanie as she was known, was
born in Paris in 1849.
12:02.119 --> 12:06.159
Her family moved to San Francisco and performed
in the French theatrical troupe.
12:07.789 --> 12:10.429
Jeannie became a well-loved child actress.
12:11.119 --> 12:15.780
The Bonets lived in the French community that
formed next to Chinatown in the 1850s.
12:16.909 --> 12:21.059
Her independent spirit became the subject of a
local newspaper report.
12:21.789 --> 12:27.690
By the time she was 15, Jeanie Bonnet evinced a
disposition to go it alone,
12:28.099 --> 12:33.140
spurning the advice of relatives and friends
and hastening down the broad road to moral
12:33.140 --> 12:36.890
destruction, she became imbued with the spirit
of heroism,
12:37.179 --> 12:41.229
and she cursed the day she was born a female
instead of a male.
12:42.239 --> 12:47.150
Jeannie was committed to the industrial school,
San Francisco's first reformatory,
12:47.679 --> 12:49.239
possibly for petty thievery.
12:50.690 --> 12:54.049
Upon her release, she organized a gang of boy
thieves.
12:55.400 --> 13:02.190
The newspaper described Jeanie as a man hater
with short cropped hair and an unwomanly voice.
13:02.190 --> 13:08.260
A masculine face which harmonized excellently
with her customary suit of boys' clothes,
13:08.750 --> 13:14.270
including a jaunty hat which she wore with all
the grace of an experienced hoodlum.
13:15.630 --> 13:19.500
Although she was arrested over 20 times for
wearing male attire,
13:19.989 --> 13:24.219
Jeanie Binet often refused to pay her fine and
went to jail instead.
13:24.510 --> 13:28.150
The police and courts condemned her choice and
declared.
13:29.179 --> 13:35.460
Such clothing leads to a woman's moral ruin
because it enables her to go and do as she
13:35.460 --> 13:40.719
pleases.
In 1875, when Jeannie was 26 years old,
13:41.409 --> 13:43.760
she began visiting San Francisco brothels.
13:45.130 --> 13:49.849
She organized an all-woman gang with members
from the brothels.
13:50.010 --> 13:54.559
These women swore off prostitution, had nothing
to do with men,
13:54.890 --> 13:58.049
and supported themselves by petty thievery and
shoplifting.
13:59.299 --> 14:03.780
Jeannie's special friend, probably her lover,
was gang member Blanche Bruneau.
14:04.909 --> 14:10.260
Blanche had arrived in San Francisco from Paris
in 1875 with a man named Arthur Deni,
14:11.390 --> 14:14.280
who had been living off Blanche's earnings as a
prostitute.
14:15.219 --> 14:17.090
Jeannie persuaded Blanche to leave him.
14:18.429 --> 14:23.780
She had resolved to step in between as many
women of Blanche's character and men of Denis's
14:23.780 --> 14:26.590
stripe as she possibly could and cause a
separation.
14:28.280 --> 14:32.460
Jeannie's life was threatened, and she was
physically attacked many times by pimps who
14:32.460 --> 14:36.609
were furious at her for stealing away the
prostitutes they considered their own property.
14:38.109 --> 14:44.109
After Blanche left Arthur and Eve, she took a
room at the San Miguel Saloon, 4 miles outside
14:44.109 --> 14:48.099
of San Francisco.
Blanche and Jeannie sometimes spent the night
14:48.099 --> 14:52.330
there together.
The owner of the saloon had known Jeannie for 6
14:52.330 --> 14:53.849
years and thought she was a man.
14:54.900 --> 15:00.809
On September 14th, 1876, Jeannie spent the
night with Blanche at the saloon.
15:01.299 --> 15:05.450
After dark, Jeannie sat in Blanche's room
smoking her pipe,
15:06.140 --> 15:08.700
drinking a cognac and talking with Blanche.
15:10.380 --> 15:14.539
She then got into bed and waited with her head
propped on her arm for Blanche to join her.
15:15.719 --> 15:20.640
Blanche sat down on the edge of the bed and
bent down to tie her shoes when a blast of
15:20.640 --> 15:25.919
buckshot came flying through the window,
tearing through Jeanie's body in six places and
15:25.919 --> 15:27.179
killing Jeanie Bonnet.
15:28.250 --> 15:30.900
The murder case was never solved.
15:31.179 --> 15:34.640
Police and the press believed it was plotted by
angry pimps.
15:35.690 --> 15:39.469
But only one pimp was questioned and later
released for lack of evidence.
15:40.460 --> 15:44.409
The day after the murder, the city morgue was
thronged with people.
15:45.130 --> 15:47.049
The newspapers described the scene.
15:48.500 --> 15:55.219
Most of them were attracted by a strong desire
to gaze upon the face of such a strange girl.
15:56.380 --> 16:02.929
The body was arrayed in white, contrasting
strongly with her sun-browned and
16:02.929 --> 16:04.280
weather-beaten face.
16:04.960 --> 16:11.940
Her short hair was combed back neatly, and some
kind soul placed a white flower in
16:11.940 --> 16:12.979
her hands.
16:15.309 --> 16:21.229
Jeannie Bonnet was buried in the Oddfellows
Cemetery near San Francisco's Lone Mountain.
16:30.950 --> 16:36.239
In August 1897, the police in Stockton,
California,
16:36.969 --> 16:41.419
a small but growing city 75 miles east of San
Francisco.
16:42.239 --> 16:46.640
Arrested a 22-year-old woman masquerading in
men's clothing.
16:47.559 --> 16:49.000
She did not speak a word.
16:49.679 --> 16:52.500
But she wrote out her story for police and
reporters.
16:53.669 --> 16:57.070
She had lost her speech in an accident, she
explained.
16:58.109 --> 16:59.929
Her neighbors called her Jack.
17:00.890 --> 17:05.709
But her name was Babe Bean, and she had hiked
alone from Southern California.
17:06.829 --> 17:12.869
Babe Bean lived on a houseboat or ark on
McCloud's Lake near Stockton.
17:13.729 --> 17:20.448
She wore a blue suit, white silk shirt, large
shoes, and a hat pulled down over her eyes.
17:21.430 --> 17:24.880
I have been wearing men's clothing off and on
for five years,
17:25.109 --> 17:29.800
she wrote, for as a man I can travel freely,
feel protected,
17:29.810 --> 17:31.010
and find work.
17:32.650 --> 17:38.760
Babe Bean refused to reveal her family origins,
but she claimed they were one of the best in
17:38.760 --> 17:42.449
the land.
She spoke affectionately of her father who was
17:42.449 --> 17:47.459
dead and her brother whose clothes she used to
wear, of her mother,
17:47.579 --> 17:51.209
she explained.
I loved my mother with all my heart,
17:51.459 --> 17:55.739
but I feared even to talk to her at times lest
my rough manner might offend her.
17:56.660 --> 18:01.760
From a tomboy full of ambitions, I was made
into a sad and thoughtful woman.
18:01.979 --> 18:03.849
I commenced to be rebellious.
18:04.180 --> 18:08.489
My mother feared for my future and thought that
nothing but a convent would save me,
18:08.619 --> 18:09.739
and there I remained.
18:10.500 --> 18:15.900
How I yearned for that freedom I dreamed of and
how often I wished I could enjoy the liberty
18:15.900 --> 18:18.130
that the world sees fit to allow a boy.
18:18.969 --> 18:25.119
At the age of 15, she decided to marry her
brother's best friend in order to escape the
18:25.119 --> 18:27.160
convent and see the world.
18:28.579 --> 18:32.599
What I have suffered for that act, no one can
ever know,
18:32.890 --> 18:38.040
she explained.
Within a few months, she divorced her husband.
18:38.290 --> 18:41.520
And set out on her own, passing as a man.
18:42.050 --> 18:46.930
For four years, she lived in the mountains, on city
streets, and in hobo camps.
18:47.760 --> 18:51.819
The people of Stockton became fascinated with
the phenomenon of Babe Bean,
18:52.390 --> 18:57.780
the ark dweller in man's attire, and they
began to treat her with affectionate curiosity.
18:58.550 --> 19:03.550
For months, her every movement made front page
news in the Stockton newspapers.
19:04.219 --> 19:09.650
Stories of the trouser puzzle reached the San
Francisco and Boston papers.
19:10.569 --> 19:16.560
The Stockton Bachelor's Club made Babe Bean an
honorary member and the guest of honor at a
19:16.560 --> 19:20.859
dinner.
One newspaper article told of Babe Bean's
19:20.859 --> 19:22.689
popularity with women as well.
19:24.000 --> 19:27.949
Several fashionable ladies invited her to spend
the evening with them,
19:28.439 --> 19:32.319
but Babe Bean said that she declined to put
herself on exhibition.
19:33.319 --> 19:39.920
Many women, both young and old, drove or walked
past her ark in order to catch a glimpse of her.
19:41.699 --> 19:46.300
She never got along with feminine women, and
tomboys were her closest chums.
19:47.880 --> 19:49.589
Was she then a woman hater?
19:50.439 --> 19:56.109
No, indeed, she wrote on her pad, underlining
the indeed several times.
19:57.599 --> 20:01.439
Babe Bean was hired by the Stockton Evening
Mail as a reporter.
20:02.079 --> 20:05.510
And assigned to cover the baby show at the San
Joaquin County Fair.
20:06.189 --> 20:10.040
An annual event where mothers displayed their
newborn babies for prizes.
20:11.219 --> 20:15.869
First, she made it clear that she was not
interested in having a child herself.
20:16.619 --> 20:21.489
Then she described what each baby wore and how
sickly or healthy each looked,
20:21.890 --> 20:25.609
and she defended the right of a black woman to
enter her child in the contest.
20:27.270 --> 20:33.469
Soon after her discovery, some criticisms of
Babe Bean's freedom appeared in the editorial
20:33.469 --> 20:37.540
pages of the newspaper signed by the Girl of
Stockton.
20:38.550 --> 20:43.989
What puzzles us girls is why Babe Bean should
be allowed to dress that way.
20:44.239 --> 20:48.630
Well, if any of the rest of us wanted to walk
out in that kind of costume for a change,
20:49.000 --> 20:51.510
we would be arrested quicker than quick.
20:52.209 --> 20:56.910
There used to be a law against females dressing
like males,
20:57.400 --> 21:00.869
but it seems not to apply to Babe Bean.
21:01.250 --> 21:05.510
If Babe Bean is a girl and continues to dress
in boys' clothes,
21:05.810 --> 21:11.959
the rest of us ought to have the same privilege,
and we are going to do it some fine evening.
21:12.160 --> 21:15.750
There are going to be about 25 young women on
the streets of Stockton,
21:16.079 --> 21:18.199
all dressed in men's clothing.
21:18.540 --> 21:23.599
And we're going to go to the ark and get Babe
Bean and duck her in McLeod's Lake till she
21:23.599 --> 21:28.030
cries enough.
Then she can talk if she wants to.
21:28.609 --> 21:29.780
Babe Bean replied.
21:30.540 --> 21:35.770
It is your privilege to dress as you see fit,
whether it is after the fashion of Venus or
21:35.770 --> 21:37.410
after the fashion of Babe Bean.
21:38.050 --> 21:42.920
I wish to state that boys' clothes are still
selling in Stockton at reduced prices.
21:43.079 --> 21:44.959
You are quite welcome to that information.
21:46.280 --> 21:48.829
She added that she was quite capable of
defending herself.
21:49.829 --> 21:53.739
Another, more supportive letter appeared in the
newspaper.
21:54.640 --> 22:00.180
I do not know Babe Bean, but she's a woman, and
I don't think it's a woman's place to try to
22:00.180 --> 22:03.839
injure a sister because she does not happen to
live just as we do.
22:04.469 --> 22:08.760
And if she wants to wear men's clothes and have
16 pockets,
22:09.130 --> 22:10.449
it's none of our business.
22:12.040 --> 22:17.339
In 1898, when war was declared between the
United States and Spain,
22:17.709 --> 22:23.280
the front-page articles about Babe Bean were
replaced by accounts of Stockton's own recruits
22:23.589 --> 22:25.939
leaving for Cuba or the Philippines.
22:26.229 --> 22:32.550
Babe Bean disappeared from Stockton, but a
small man named Jack Garland was one of those
22:32.550 --> 22:36.270
who boarded a transport ship for the
Philippines.
22:36.589 --> 22:40.349
Garland served as a lieutenant during the
Spanish-American War.
22:41.229 --> 22:48.150
He later moved to San Francisco where, in 1906,
he served as a male nurse during
22:48.150 --> 22:53.040
the great earthquake and fire, providing
emergency medical care to homeless San
22:53.040 --> 22:57.619
Franciscans.
Garland received personal commendation from the
22:57.619 --> 23:00.699
military commander of the city, General Funston.
23:01.969 --> 23:08.410
For the next 30 years, Jack Garland lived in
San Francisco rooming houses and acted as a
23:08.410 --> 23:12.239
kind of freelance social worker aiding homeless
and hungry people.
23:13.030 --> 23:17.650
He was affectionately known as Uncle Jack by
those who knew and loved him.
23:18.020 --> 23:24.849
On the evening of September 18th, 1936, this
little old man with a big heart
23:25.339 --> 23:30.180
collapsed and was taken to a hospital where
attendants did not realize at first that he was
23:30.180 --> 23:34.670
really a woman.
They were deceived by his masculine clothes and
23:34.670 --> 23:40.699
voice, by the profuse tattooing on his arms,
and by friends who called him Uncle Jack.
23:41.849 --> 23:44.530
Two days later, Jack Garland died.
23:45.400 --> 23:49.969
His death revealed not only his true sex but
also his true identity.
23:51.000 --> 23:57.859
Sixty-six-year-old Uncle Jack, alias Babe Bean, had once
been Elvira
23:57.859 --> 24:04.760
Virginia Mugarrieta, the daughter of Jose Marcos
Mugarrieta, who founded the Mexican
24:04.760 --> 24:06.329
consulate in San Francisco.
24:07.219 --> 24:13.180
Her mother, Eliza Alice Garland, was said to be
the daughter of a Louisiana Supreme Court
24:13.180 --> 24:19.959
Justice.
Jack, Babe, Elvira was buried in San Francisco.
24:19.959 --> 24:21.229
With the rest of her family.
24:33.359 --> 24:39.439
By the time of Bay Bean's death, women's lives
had changed dramatically since the Victorian
24:39.439 --> 24:44.500
era.
In the early 20th century, more women than ever
24:44.810 --> 24:46.010
worked for wages.
24:47.199 --> 24:48.569
Attended college.
24:50.630 --> 24:54.060
and trained for formerly male professions.
24:55.560 --> 25:00.510
In addition, millions of women participated in
political movements.
25:01.989 --> 25:03.540
They organized workers.
25:05.130 --> 25:06.530
Supported pacifism.
25:07.709 --> 25:09.140
Demanded suffrage.
25:09.949 --> 25:15.390
And after 1920, they voted as citizens.
25:16.780 --> 25:23.130
By the 1920s, the stereotype of the prudish
Victorian woman had given way to the image of
25:23.130 --> 25:28.069
the new woman.
The flapper who smoked, drank,
25:28.319 --> 25:30.560
and had heterosexual relationships.
25:31.449 --> 25:38.430
At the same time, many women friends formed
loving relationships at
25:38.430 --> 25:40.349
school or in the workplace.
25:41.979 --> 25:46.619
Some set up mutual households known as Boston
marriages.
25:47.020 --> 25:53.569
We do not know if all of these women were
lesbians, but the evidence suggests that some
25:53.569 --> 25:58.739
no doubt were.
In a few social settings, women did live
25:58.739 --> 26:05.719
explicitly lesbian lives in exile in France, in
Bohemian neighborhoods such as Greenwich
26:05.719 --> 26:10.790
Village, or in urban black communities such as
Harlem.
26:15.130 --> 26:19.530
I'm a good mama, don't mocking me.
26:20.209 --> 26:21.680
And let me.
26:25.880 --> 26:31.449
Despite these economic, political, and sexual
changes in women's lives,
26:31.689 --> 26:35.209
the phenomenon of passing women did not
disappear.
26:35.989 --> 26:39.609
In fact, newspapers frequently reported stories
about them.
26:41.800 --> 26:48.750
In 1925, the marriage of Peter Stratford and
Elizabeth Rowland made headlines.
26:49.650 --> 26:56.400
Other articles revealed the lives of passing
women such as Nora Barnes,
26:56.569 --> 27:02.040
Pauline Allen, Francis Orlando, Minerva Phipps,
and Mabel Eagan Radcliffe.
27:03.390 --> 27:08.589
During the Depression of the 1930s, women
hoboes sometimes passed as men.
27:11.050 --> 27:17.729
After 1920, women who occasionally wore men's
clothing and those who passed as men began to
27:17.729 --> 27:20.810
socialize more openly in cafes and nightclubs.
27:21.930 --> 27:26.040
The best known were in Paris, the original
lesbian bars.
27:26.900 --> 27:33.189
In America, two Chicago nightclubs run by women
were closed by the police during the
27:33.189 --> 27:39.869
1930s because women in male attire were nightly
patrons of the places.
27:40.270 --> 27:45.069
Many of the couples who frequented these clubs
had been married to each other by a black
27:45.069 --> 27:46.910
minister on Chicago's South Side.
27:48.010 --> 27:54.439
And in San Francisco lesbians met at Mona's
where it was
27:54.439 --> 27:58.130
said girls will be boys.
27:58.439 --> 28:02.630
Public attitudes towards passing women changed
in the early 20th century,
28:02.920 --> 28:05.760
imposing stricter penalties on cross-dressing.
28:06.709 --> 28:10.689
In addition to the older legal sanctions
against passing,
28:11.089 --> 28:17.130
new medical and psychiatric theories labeled
these women as sexual deviants.
28:18.469 --> 28:23.310
On the one hand, the doctors did at least
recognize that women could have sexual desires
28:23.310 --> 28:26.229
for and relationships with other women.
28:26.959 --> 28:32.640
But on the other hand, they attempted to
discourage these relationships by categorizing
28:32.640 --> 28:33.880
them as sick.
28:35.000 --> 28:40.170
The psychological labels they invented for
passing women would haunt lesbians,
28:40.270 --> 28:43.630
feminists, and female friends for generations.
28:44.280 --> 28:50.469
Inverts, tributists, sapphists, men, women,
hermaphrodites, gyanders,
28:50.510 --> 28:56.380
feminosexuals, uranias, women who suffered from
various disorders,
28:56.589 --> 28:58.910
and delusional masculinity.
29:00.010 --> 29:05.800
Passing women had their own positive language
to describe themselves within the social
29:05.800 --> 29:12.680
networks they created in the 1870s.
The word dike referred to a man who
29:12.680 --> 29:17.800
was all dressed up or diked out, perhaps for a
night on the town.
29:18.800 --> 29:25.510
By 1900, the word bullyker had come into use in
the red light district of Philadelphia
29:26.030 --> 29:32.949
to mean lesbian lovers, and in 1935, black
blues singer Bessie
29:32.949 --> 29:39.819
Jackson recorded a song titled BD Woman,
meaning bull
29:39.819 --> 29:43.680
dagger woman.
Which described gay women as a group.
29:45.170 --> 29:51.609
Her song is a fitting conclusion to this story,
for it is a rare black lesbian voice from the
29:51.609 --> 29:57.609
past and a testament to the newly visible urban
lesbians who inherited the
29:57.609 --> 30:01.250
tradition of women who passed as men.
30:10.329 --> 30:12.439
In a time.
30:13.170 --> 30:15.089
the women they need.
30:20.119 --> 30:24.859
man the women's.
30:32.449 --> 30:36.109
All.
A low down and dirty.
30:39.290 --> 30:42.770
Women Oh
30:49.050 --> 30:53.060
I you on.
30:59.170 --> 31:00.739
Got a like a.
31:02.510 --> 31:03.640
It was just like.
31:07.410 --> 31:12.079
We women, women, you know they will.
31:16.520 --> 31:21.880
We the women.
Women, you know, they show is.
31:26.880 --> 31:29.109
They, I drink up many ways.
31:34.880 --> 31:39.630
We women, you know, work and make do.
31:43.520 --> 31:44.619
The women.
31:46.209 --> 31:49.439
You know, they can make that.
31:53.500 --> 31:58.050
And when they get ready to spend it in the day.