An allegory for a working class suburb in decline, this film investigates…
An Injury To One
- Description
- Reviews
- Citation
- Cataloging
- Transcript
If you are not affiliated with a college or university, and are interested in watching this film, please register as an individual and login to rent this film. Already registered? Login to rent this film. This film is also available on our home streaming platform, OVID.tv.
AN INJURY TO ONE provides a corrective-and absolutely compelling-glimpse of a particularly volatile moment in early 20th century American labor history: the rise and fall of Butte, Montana. Specifically, it chronicles the mysterious death of Wobbly organizer Frank Little, a story whose grisly details have taken on a legendary status in the state. Much of the extant evidence is inscribed upon the landscape of Butte and its surroundings. Thus, a connection is drawn between the unsolved murder of Little, and the attempted murder of the town itself.
Butte's history was entirely shaped by its exploitation by the Anaconda Mining Company, which, at the height of WWI, produced ten percent of the world's copper from the town's depths. War profiteering and the company's extreme indifference to the safety of its employees (mortality rates in the mines were higher than in the trenches of Europe) led to Little's arrival. 'The agitator' found in the desperate, agonized miners overwhelming support for his ideas, which included the abolishment of the wage system and the establishment of a socialist commonwealth.
In August 1917, Little was abducted by still-unknown assailants who hung him from a railroad bridge. Pinned to his chest was a note that read 3'-7'-77', dimensions of a Montana grave. Eight thousand people attended his funeral, the largest in Butte's history.
The murder provides AN INJURY TO ONE with a taut, suspenseful narrative, but it isn't the only story. Butte's history is bound with the entire history of the American left, the rise of McCarthyism, the destruction of the environment, and even the birth of the detective novel. Former Pinkerton detective Dashiell Hammett was rumored to have been involved in the murder, and later depicted it in Red Harvest.
Archival footage mixes with deftly deployed intertitles, while the lyrics to traditional mining songs are accompanied by music from William Oldham, Jim O'Rourke, and the band Low, producing an appropriately moody, effulgent, and strangely out-of-time soundtrack. The result is a unique film/video hybrid that combines painterly images, incisive writing, and a bold graphic sensibility to produce an articulate example of the aesthetic and political possibilities offered by filmmaking in the digital age.
'One of American independent cinema's great achievements of the past decade.' -Dennis Lim, Los Angeles Times
'An astonishing document: part art and part speculative inquiry, buzzing with ambition and dedication. Takes us from the 19th century to the eve of the 21st, from Butte as land of frontier promise to Butte as land of death and environmental destruction. He wields avant-garde graphics and archival ephemera like a lasso, and his shots of modern-day Butte are allusive still-lifes that defy time and place. This is stirring, must-see stuff.'-Austin Chronicle
'A deft, ambitious exercise in old-school socialist agitprop crafted with the precise mulitmedia flair of a corporate Powerpoint presentation, Travis Wilkerson's AN INJURY TO ONE retells the gritty class struggles of the previous century through smoothly contemporary digital means.'-The Village Voice
'The most exciting documentary of the season. Passionate, persuasive, and beautifully designed, AN INJURY TO ONE is a model of coherent political filmmaking as convincing in its liberalism as its formalism.'-The New York Sun
'Wilkerson's austere technique radically responds to the paucity of contemporaneous documentary accounts, performing a powerful act of historical archaeology and reclaiming for the working class its status as subject, not a footnote, of historical events. Wilkerson makes these ghostly historical agents palpable and vocal, asserting the relevance of their story to struggles of today and tomorrow.' -Sundance Film Festival
'I was genuinely knocked out by AN INJURY TO ONE. I loved... the way in which the film manages to be both startlingly beautiful and distressing at the same time, the counterpoint of the firm, almost dispassionate voice and the plaintive and elegiac cinematography.'-John Gianvito, Harvard Film Archives
Citation
Main credits
Wilkerson, Travis (narrator)
Wilkerson, Travis (filmmaker)
Distributor subjects
American Studies; Business and Economics; Cinema Studies; Ecology; Economics; Environment; Geography; History (U.S.); Human Rights; Labor Studies; Music; Political Science; Social MovementsKeywords
1
01:00:07,005 --> 01:02:30,147
[music playing]
2
01:02:30,281 --> 01:02:31,982
This is the novel, Red Harvest.
3
01:02:32,116 --> 01:02:34,852
It was completed in 1929 by
the American writer Dashiell
4
01:02:34,986 --> 01:02:35,886
Hammett.
5
01:02:36,020 --> 01:02:37,654
The novel is said
to be based loosely
6
01:02:37,788 --> 01:02:39,256
on Hammett's experiences
while working
7
01:02:39,391 --> 01:02:42,359
as an operative for the
Pinkerton Detective Agency.
8
01:02:42,494 --> 01:02:45,496
Butte, Montana was one of
the places he was assigned.
9
01:02:45,630 --> 01:02:47,798
The novel is regarded as a
watershed in the development
10
01:02:47,932 --> 01:02:49,399
of the crime genre.
11
01:02:49,534 --> 01:02:53,237
Some have gone so far as to
describe it as revolutionary.
12
01:02:53,371 --> 01:02:56,240
The book is marked by the
austere immediacy of its style
13
01:02:56,374 --> 01:03:00,411
and for its suffusion
with pitiless finds.
14
01:03:00,545 --> 01:03:03,247
The action is set in a
vanquished Western mining town.
15
01:03:03,381 --> 01:03:05,148
The town once
thrived but has now
16
01:03:05,283 --> 01:03:08,718
been overtaken by opportunists
and criminals of every stripe.
17
01:03:08,853 --> 01:03:11,955
It is in the grip
of organized crime.
18
01:03:12,090 --> 01:03:13,623
The catalyst for
this transformation
19
01:03:13,758 --> 01:03:15,359
is the struggle
undertaken by those
20
01:03:15,493 --> 01:03:17,394
who own the mining company
against the organizing
21
01:03:17,528 --> 01:03:19,562
efforts of a radical union.
22
01:03:19,697 --> 01:03:21,198
Though the book is
a work of fiction,
23
01:03:21,332 --> 01:03:23,833
there is no doubting
its real inspiration.
24
01:03:23,968 --> 01:03:26,537
Hammett called his
fictional town Poisonville.
25
01:03:26,671 --> 01:03:30,373
He couldn't guess how it
would resound 70 years later.
26
01:03:30,507 --> 01:03:55,465
[music playing]
27
01:03:55,599 --> 01:03:57,868
It is 1864.
28
01:03:58,002 --> 01:04:00,637
The Montana territory
is carved out of Idaho,
29
01:04:00,771 --> 01:04:04,308
and a colonial
economy is adopted.
30
01:04:04,442 --> 01:04:07,110
From the inception of the
territory, all of Montana's
31
01:04:07,245 --> 01:04:10,881
[? saline ?] industries
are extractive.
32
01:04:11,015 --> 01:04:12,983
According to this
model, the object
33
01:04:13,117 --> 01:04:17,787
is to trap it, shoot it,
mine it, and get out.
34
01:04:17,922 --> 01:04:19,623
In the century and
a half that follows,
35
01:04:19,758 --> 01:04:23,594
this model will never be
successfully challenged.
36
01:04:23,728 --> 01:04:26,930
Soon after its founding, miners
from the depleted gold fields
37
01:04:27,064 --> 01:04:29,133
of California and
Colorado begin to migrate
38
01:04:29,267 --> 01:04:32,102
into the new territory.
39
01:04:32,236 --> 01:04:34,371
They are fueled by
unrequited dreams
40
01:04:34,506 --> 01:04:40,611
and found a mining camp that
will one day become Butte.
41
01:04:40,744 --> 01:04:43,780
It is 1873.
42
01:04:43,914 --> 01:04:46,584
The gold boom has
fallen into a bust.
43
01:04:46,718 --> 01:04:48,319
The restless population
of the territory
44
01:04:48,453 --> 01:04:51,622
has now shifted to the Dakotas.
45
01:04:51,756 --> 01:04:53,590
Butte is described
as a deplorable place
46
01:04:53,725 --> 01:04:58,295
with no newspaper, no church,
and only a single school.
47
01:04:58,429 --> 01:05:00,597
It has been reduced a little
more than primitive shacks
48
01:05:00,731 --> 01:05:03,300
and muddy pads.
49
01:05:03,434 --> 01:05:12,442
The town of Butte, not yet fully
born, is nearly left for dead.
50
01:05:12,576 --> 01:05:14,878
It is 1882.
51
01:05:15,012 --> 01:05:17,714
The age of electricity is gone.
52
01:05:17,848 --> 01:05:19,883
A massive body of
copper is discovered
53
01:05:20,017 --> 01:05:22,319
below the hills of Butte.
54
01:05:22,453 --> 01:05:24,521
Because copper is essential
to electrification,
55
01:05:24,655 --> 01:05:28,525
Butte begins to boom.
56
01:05:28,660 --> 01:05:33,297
The town is soon crowded
with new arrivals.
57
01:05:33,431 --> 01:05:35,265
The company that
will soon rule Butte
58
01:05:35,400 --> 01:05:44,141
is founded and takes the
name of a famed predator. m
59
01:05:44,275 --> 01:05:45,509
It is 1889.
60
01:05:45,643 --> 01:05:49,146
The War of the Copper
Kings has begun.
61
01:05:49,280 --> 01:05:50,713
In this struggle,
competing owners
62
01:05:50,848 --> 01:05:52,415
try to challenge
Anaconda's domination
63
01:05:52,549 --> 01:05:55,218
of the mines of Butte.
64
01:05:55,353 --> 01:05:57,721
Soon after, the first
scheming of the Butte miners,
65
01:05:57,856 --> 01:06:00,624
the Western Federation
of Miners, is founded,
66
01:06:00,759 --> 01:06:03,761
and owners, weakened by
their internecine struggle,
67
01:06:03,895 --> 01:06:06,997
yield unprecedented
strength to the union.
68
01:06:07,131 --> 01:06:11,334
Butte is dubbed the
Gibraltar of unionism.
69
01:06:11,468 --> 01:06:14,805
It is 1903.
70
01:06:14,940 --> 01:06:19,242
Anaconda emerges the sole victor
in the War of Copper Kings.
71
01:06:19,377 --> 01:06:21,211
The mines now generate
unprecedented wealth
72
01:06:21,345 --> 01:06:24,147
for the company.
73
01:06:24,282 --> 01:06:27,484
As a result, Butte has become
the political and economic
74
01:06:27,618 --> 01:06:31,588
capital of the region.
75
01:06:31,723 --> 01:06:35,959
It is said that Anaconda
is an aptly named company.
76
01:06:36,093 --> 01:06:39,129
It seeks to strengthen
its grip on the town.
77
01:06:39,263 --> 01:06:41,965
The company purchases
newspapers, rigs elections,
78
01:06:42,099 --> 01:06:45,068
and bribes public officials.
79
01:06:45,202 --> 01:06:46,936
Judges and other agents
of law enforcement
80
01:06:47,071 --> 01:06:51,074
likewise fall under
company control.
81
01:06:51,208 --> 01:06:54,277
Historians have said any
approximately accurate history
82
01:06:54,412 --> 01:06:57,480
of the state must be, in
the large part, the story
83
01:06:57,614 --> 01:06:59,649
of modern feudalism.
84
01:06:59,783 --> 01:07:08,258
But this is incorrect.
85
01:07:08,392 --> 01:07:10,126
Anaconda soon
turns its attention
86
01:07:10,261 --> 01:07:13,063
to the sole remaining obstacle
to its absolute domination
87
01:07:13,197 --> 01:07:17,434
of Butte.
88
01:07:17,568 --> 01:07:21,705
It is 2005, and in Chicago,
a radical union is found.
89
01:07:21,840 --> 01:07:24,408
It will seek to organize all
workers within one union,
90
01:07:24,542 --> 01:07:26,710
rather than to
divide them by trade.
91
01:07:26,845 --> 01:07:28,645
Unity of action,
its members believe,
92
01:07:28,779 --> 01:07:30,680
is the key to workers' power.
93
01:07:30,815 --> 01:07:33,583
The radical union will seek to
organize those workers ignored
94
01:07:33,717 --> 01:07:35,485
by the other unions.
95
01:07:35,620 --> 01:07:38,355
Organizers will labor among
migrant farmers, timber
96
01:07:38,489 --> 01:07:41,058
workers, and hard rock miners.
97
01:07:41,193 --> 01:07:44,461
They will fight for immediate
demands, better wages, safer
98
01:07:44,595 --> 01:07:46,897
working conditions,
secure employment,
99
01:07:47,032 --> 01:07:49,566
but members of the radical union
will always fight for something
100
01:07:49,700 --> 01:07:50,935
else as well.
101
01:07:51,069 --> 01:07:53,970
They will fight for a
different kind of world.
102
01:07:54,104 --> 01:07:57,040
The union calls itself
the IWW, the Industrial
103
01:07:57,174 --> 01:07:58,909
Workers of the World.
104
01:07:59,044 --> 01:08:02,111
But its members are also
known as the Wobblies.
105
01:08:02,246 --> 01:08:05,782
The new union adopts as
its symbol the black cat,
106
01:08:05,916 --> 01:08:07,651
and this is appropriate.
107
01:08:07,785 --> 01:08:09,686
The cat is an animal
with which we do not have
108
01:08:09,820 --> 01:08:18,295
a master-servant relationship.
109
01:08:18,429 --> 01:08:20,597
It is 1912.
110
01:08:20,732 --> 01:08:24,301
Anaconda has wrested control
of the union from the miners.
111
01:08:24,435 --> 01:08:26,703
The rustling card has
replaced the union card
112
01:08:26,838 --> 01:08:29,772
and is issued only to the most
responsible men, men who are
113
01:08:29,907 --> 01:08:33,110
not disturbers and agitators.
114
01:08:33,245 --> 01:08:36,880
Anaconda can withdraw the card
at any time for any reason.
115
01:08:37,015 --> 01:08:40,283
For example, 500 miners
are fired summarily
116
01:08:40,418 --> 01:08:42,719
after being labeled socialists.
117
01:08:42,854 --> 01:08:46,190
Thus, the black list is
first implemented in Butte.
118
01:08:46,324 --> 01:08:50,393
Meanwhile, laws regarding
safety in the mines are ignored.
119
01:08:50,528 --> 01:08:52,429
Tuberculosis accounts
for nearly one third
120
01:08:52,563 --> 01:08:54,230
of all deaths in Butte.
121
01:08:54,365 --> 01:08:56,299
The miners and their
families live and work
122
01:08:56,434 --> 01:09:01,705
in deplorable conditions.
123
01:09:01,838 --> 01:09:03,139
It is 1914.
124
01:09:03,274 --> 01:09:06,442
The transformation
Butte continues apace.
125
01:09:06,577 --> 01:09:09,913
The once mighty union has now
been purged from the mines.
126
01:09:10,048 --> 01:09:13,650
The town has been partitioned
into two distinct encampments.
127
01:09:13,785 --> 01:09:16,787
A few reside in a bustling,
cosmopolitan, and prosperous
128
01:09:16,921 --> 01:09:20,056
enclave, while the sector
populated by Butte's majority
129
01:09:20,190 --> 01:09:23,860
is overcrowded,
unsanitary, and dangerous.
130
01:09:23,995 --> 01:09:26,162
Federal forces and the
declaration of martial law
131
01:09:26,297 --> 01:09:28,899
have been deemed
necessary to quell unrest.
132
01:09:29,033 --> 01:09:32,002
The town remains under
military occupation.
133
01:09:32,137 --> 01:09:34,671
While the price of copper
has increased fourfold,
134
01:09:34,806 --> 01:09:38,341
wages remained unchanged
since the previous century.
135
01:09:38,476 --> 01:10:26,022
The cost of living in
Butte is impossibly high.
136
01:10:26,156 --> 01:10:27,457
It is 1917.
137
01:10:27,591 --> 01:10:30,393
The transformation
of Butte is complete.
138
01:10:30,528 --> 01:10:33,964
From closed shop to open
shop, from union card
139
01:10:34,098 --> 01:10:37,367
to rustling card, from
collective bargaining
140
01:10:37,501 --> 01:10:40,637
to individual bargaining,
from trade agreements
141
01:10:40,771 --> 01:10:45,041
to no agreements whatsoever,
from mutual need and good will
142
01:10:45,175 --> 01:10:48,311
to riots and
militia-patrolled streets,
143
01:10:48,445 --> 01:10:53,050
from cooperation and affection
to hate and mistrust,
144
01:10:53,184 --> 01:11:00,890
from 17,500 union miners to
17,500 disorganized miners.
145
01:11:01,024 --> 01:11:03,794
It is summer.
146
01:11:03,928 --> 01:11:07,097
Washington has
joined the Great War.
147
01:11:07,232 --> 01:11:09,599
Copper is essential to the war
drive, and the mines of Butte
148
01:11:09,734 --> 01:11:12,769
produce 10% of the
world's copper.
149
01:11:12,904 --> 01:11:16,573
Thus, the war is generating
millions for the company.
150
01:11:16,707 --> 01:11:20,810
Nonetheless, the opponents
of war are numerous in Butte.
151
01:11:20,945 --> 01:11:23,313
Many are Irish immigrants who
detest the thought of fighting
152
01:11:23,447 --> 01:11:26,282
on behalf of their colonizers.
153
01:11:26,417 --> 01:11:31,087
Others blame the war on the
greed of war profiteers.
154
01:11:31,221 --> 01:11:32,856
Consider the following.
155
01:11:32,990 --> 01:11:35,025
At the height of the World
War, the mines of Butte
156
01:11:35,159 --> 01:11:37,794
produced more than 30%
of the nation's copper
157
01:11:37,929 --> 01:11:40,664
and more than 10% of
the world's copper.
158
01:11:40,798 --> 01:11:42,599
Copper is essential
to the war drive
159
01:11:42,733 --> 01:11:45,568
no less than
munitions or bodies.
160
01:11:45,703 --> 01:11:47,904
Because Anaconda owns
the mines of Butte,
161
01:11:48,039 --> 01:11:50,640
the company wields tremendous
power on a national scale
162
01:11:50,774 --> 01:11:52,009
as well.
163
01:11:52,143 --> 01:11:54,244
The company uses this
considerable influence
164
01:11:54,379 --> 01:11:57,647
to inflate the price of
copper sold to the government.
165
01:11:57,782 --> 01:11:59,883
Copper is essential
to the war drive,
166
01:12:00,017 --> 01:12:04,021
no less than munitions or
bodies, so the government pays,
167
01:12:04,155 --> 01:12:05,922
and Anaconda extracts
millions from what
168
01:12:06,056 --> 01:12:08,125
is needed to wage war.
169
01:12:08,259 --> 01:12:10,793
This is what is meant by the
old fashioned phrase, war
170
01:12:10,927 --> 01:12:12,428
profiteering.
171
01:12:12,563 --> 01:12:14,731
And how can a company
making millions from war
172
01:12:14,865 --> 01:12:18,301
ever oppose such a war?
173
01:12:18,435 --> 01:12:20,270
Such explanations of
the First World War
174
01:12:20,404 --> 01:12:22,472
are now said to be inadequate.
175
01:12:22,606 --> 01:12:24,474
But even now, who
can truly explain
176
01:12:24,608 --> 01:12:27,210
the causes of that war in
which the cold efficiencies
177
01:12:27,344 --> 01:12:29,245
of industry finally
collided head
178
01:12:29,379 --> 01:12:36,419
on with the savage
capacities of humankind?
179
01:12:36,553 --> 01:12:38,955
The rate of mortality is
higher in the mines of Butte
180
01:12:39,089 --> 01:12:42,158
and in the trenches of Europe.
181
01:12:42,293 --> 01:12:47,063
Production continues as the
town remains under occupation.
182
01:12:47,198 --> 01:13:00,343
Xenophobia and a constant fear
of violence pervade Butte.
183
01:13:00,477 --> 01:14:53,757
[music playing]
184
01:14:53,891 --> 01:14:56,692
It is the 8th of June.
185
01:14:56,827 --> 01:15:02,299
Fire is triggered in a
shaft called the Speculator.
186
01:15:02,433 --> 01:15:04,801
Flames spread rapidly
through ventilation shafts,
187
01:15:04,935 --> 01:15:08,504
and the Speculator
is soon engulfed.
188
01:15:08,639 --> 01:15:10,406
Word of the fire
reaches town quickly,
189
01:15:10,540 --> 01:15:13,442
and thousands make
their way to the site.
190
01:15:13,577 --> 01:15:19,449
The rescue work
continues for days.
191
01:15:19,584 --> 01:15:22,418
In order to keep the work going,
rescuers are offered whisky
192
01:15:22,552 --> 01:15:24,287
at the mouth of the mine.
193
01:15:24,422 --> 01:15:27,057
They will discover the dead
piled against cement bulkheads,
194
01:15:27,191 --> 01:15:30,493
and most are charred
beyond recognition.
195
01:15:30,627 --> 01:15:32,395
State law specifies
that the bulkheads
196
01:15:32,530 --> 01:15:35,298
must have doors which can be
opened in the case of fire
197
01:15:35,432 --> 01:15:37,434
or collapse.
198
01:15:37,568 --> 01:15:42,305
The fingers of the dead are
said to be worn to the knuckles.
199
01:15:42,440 --> 01:15:50,847
It is clear-- the law is
ignored in the minds of Butte.
200
01:15:50,981 --> 01:15:53,816
164 finally perish in the fire.
201
01:15:53,951 --> 01:15:58,688
It is the worst mining accident
in the nation's history.
202
01:15:58,822 --> 01:16:00,924
Butte has for some
time been a volcano
203
01:16:01,058 --> 01:16:03,260
on the point of eruption,
and the heavy toll
204
01:16:03,394 --> 01:16:05,428
of life in the
Speculator catastrophe
205
01:16:05,562 --> 01:16:11,634
proves to be the flaming torch.
206
01:16:11,768 --> 01:16:14,304
It is the 11th of June.
207
01:16:14,438 --> 01:16:17,807
The mines are idled
by a massive strike.
208
01:16:17,941 --> 01:16:21,611
The miners are joined on the
pickets by the trade unions.
209
01:16:21,745 --> 01:16:23,880
A new miners' union is founded.
210
01:16:24,014 --> 01:16:28,118
The Metal Mine Workers Union
soon issues its demands.
211
01:16:28,252 --> 01:16:33,123
16,000 workers
observe the pickets.
212
01:16:33,257 --> 01:16:34,791
Company papers assert
that the strike
213
01:16:34,925 --> 01:16:37,160
is part of a conspiracy
led by German agents
214
01:16:37,294 --> 01:16:40,963
with the intention
of aiding the enemy.
215
01:16:41,098 --> 01:16:44,367
Company papers predict
violence, yet no violence
216
01:16:44,502 --> 01:16:49,905
among the strikers is
seen or is reported.
217
01:16:50,040 --> 01:16:53,309
Nevertheless, Anaconda refuses
to recognize the new miners'
218
01:16:53,443 --> 01:16:55,478
union.
219
01:16:55,613 --> 01:16:58,314
It will close the mines
down, flood them, and not
220
01:16:58,448 --> 01:16:59,815
raise a pound of
copper before it
221
01:16:59,950 --> 01:17:05,489
will recognize the anarchist
leaders of the new union.
222
01:17:05,623 --> 01:17:07,390
The company then seeks
to isolate the miners
223
01:17:07,525 --> 01:17:09,926
by offering better contracts
to the trade unions,
224
01:17:10,060 --> 01:17:13,496
and the trade unions
accept the offer.
225
01:17:13,630 --> 01:17:15,398
The workers of
Butte are divided,
226
01:17:15,533 --> 01:17:18,134
and Anaconda seems
poised for victory.
227
01:17:18,269 --> 01:17:25,208
But a new factor is
introduced to the equation.
228
01:17:25,341 --> 01:17:27,010
It is 1879.
229
01:17:27,144 --> 01:17:29,579
An agitator is born in Oklahoma.
230
01:17:29,713 --> 01:17:31,848
He is named Frank Little.
231
01:17:31,982 --> 01:17:34,717
There are few extant
details of his life.
232
01:17:34,851 --> 01:17:37,887
He is born of a white father
and a Cherokee mother.
233
01:17:38,021 --> 01:17:40,523
He will later be described
as half white, half Indian,
234
01:17:40,657 --> 01:17:43,092
and all IWW.
235
01:17:43,227 --> 01:17:45,261
He joins the radical union
and dedicates himself
236
01:17:45,395 --> 01:17:46,996
to the class struggle.
237
01:17:47,131 --> 01:17:48,731
He has three brothers
and two sisters
238
01:17:48,865 --> 01:17:51,301
who will join him as agitators.
239
01:17:51,435 --> 01:17:54,603
He is a fearless and
indefatigable organizer.
240
01:17:54,738 --> 01:17:56,606
His name is inseparable
from the struggles which
241
01:17:56,741 --> 01:18:01,010
marked the era, Bisbee, the
Great Central Valley, the Iron
242
01:18:01,145 --> 01:18:03,813
Range, and finally, Butte.
243
01:18:03,947 --> 01:18:05,915
He is jailed repeatedly.
244
01:18:06,049 --> 01:18:10,053
He connects the fight for free
speech with the class struggle.
245
01:18:10,187 --> 01:18:12,055
Because of the role of
money in our society,
246
01:18:12,189 --> 01:18:14,023
free speech is not free.
247
01:18:14,158 --> 01:18:16,526
If we cannot speak,
how can we discuss?
248
01:18:16,661 --> 01:18:20,296
And if we cannot discuss,
how can we invent?
249
01:18:20,431 --> 01:18:23,599
Frank Little is an outspoken
opponent of the Great War.
250
01:18:23,733 --> 01:18:25,034
War will mean the
end of everything
251
01:18:25,169 --> 01:18:27,303
he has ever fought
for-- free speech,
252
01:18:27,437 --> 01:18:29,505
a free press, free assembly.
253
01:18:29,639 --> 01:18:32,108
He will take the
firing squad first.
254
01:18:32,242 --> 01:18:34,310
While agitating among
the miners of Iron River,
255
01:18:34,444 --> 01:18:36,413
his future is foreshadowed.
256
01:18:36,547 --> 01:18:37,880
He is assigned by
the radical union
257
01:18:38,015 --> 01:18:40,350
to agitate among
the miners of Butte.
258
01:18:40,484 --> 01:18:43,119
He departs from Montana
at the age of 38.
259
01:18:43,253 --> 01:18:50,459
He bears the scars of
struggles elsewhere.
260
01:18:50,593 --> 01:20:58,921
[music playing]
261
01:20:59,055 --> 01:21:02,792
It is the 18th of July, 1917.
262
01:21:02,926 --> 01:21:16,972
The Agitator arrives by train.
263
01:21:17,107 --> 01:21:18,841
The day after his
arrival, he is invited
264
01:21:18,975 --> 01:21:21,411
to speak to a gathering
of the striking miners,
265
01:21:21,545 --> 01:21:25,681
and more than 6,000
come to hear him speak.
266
01:21:25,815 --> 01:21:27,416
He addresses immediate goals.
267
01:21:27,551 --> 01:21:39,362
He describes an image of
a different kind of world.
268
01:21:39,496 --> 01:21:41,030
Company papers
describe his remarks
269
01:21:41,164 --> 01:21:43,666
as a treasonable tirade.
270
01:21:43,801 --> 01:21:46,935
Under a headline which reads,
"Soldiers called armed thugs,"
271
01:21:47,070 --> 01:21:50,272
they write, "Frank Little,
Arizona strike leader,
272
01:21:50,407 --> 01:21:52,408
practically threatened the
United States government
273
01:21:52,542 --> 01:21:54,377
with revolution."
274
01:21:54,511 --> 01:21:56,745
6,000 men filled the
bleachers to overflowing
275
01:21:56,880 --> 01:21:59,148
and listened to
Little's remarks.
276
01:21:59,282 --> 01:22:02,685
The frail man worked
himself into a maniacal fury
277
01:22:02,820 --> 01:22:06,656
as he denounced the capitalists
of every class and nationality.
278
01:22:06,790 --> 01:22:08,591
Little intimated a
worldwide revolution
279
01:22:08,725 --> 01:22:12,828
of the working classes.
280
01:22:12,962 --> 01:22:14,830
After Little's first
appearance, the papers
281
01:22:14,964 --> 01:22:19,569
reiterate their
prediction of violence.
282
01:22:19,703 --> 01:22:21,970
On July 25th, the
Agitator is invited
283
01:22:22,105 --> 01:22:25,408
to address closed meetings
of the miner's union.
284
01:22:25,542 --> 01:22:27,042
These meetings are
said to be comprised
285
01:22:27,177 --> 01:22:32,114
in equal parts of laborers
and company spies.
286
01:22:32,249 --> 01:22:34,951
The Agitator discusses tactics.
287
01:22:35,086 --> 01:22:38,153
We have no set rules to go
by, but we are organized,
288
01:22:38,288 --> 01:22:40,156
and when we call a strike,
we must use any means
289
01:22:40,290 --> 01:22:42,158
necessary to win that strike.
290
01:22:42,292 --> 01:22:44,059
That's the reason the
boss doesn't like us.
291
01:22:44,194 --> 01:22:46,395
He can't handle us, and he
knows that we will handle him
292
01:22:46,529 --> 01:22:47,930
in the near future.
293
01:22:48,064 --> 01:22:49,732
Use any means necessary.
294
01:22:49,867 --> 01:22:52,235
It doesn't matter what those
means are, but use them
295
01:22:52,369 --> 01:22:56,405
to win your strike.
296
01:22:56,540 --> 01:22:59,074
On July 27th, the
Agitator is invited
297
01:22:59,209 --> 01:23:01,844
to address the miners
for a second time.
298
01:23:01,978 --> 01:23:06,982
On this occasion, 6,500
are said to attend.
299
01:23:07,117 --> 01:23:09,518
He addresses immediate goals.
300
01:23:09,653 --> 01:23:14,557
He describes an image of
a different kind of world.
301
01:23:14,691 --> 01:23:16,826
He is said to have described
Woodrow Wilson as a lying
302
01:23:16,960 --> 01:23:18,093
tyrant.
303
01:23:18,228 --> 01:23:20,129
He is said to have claimed
that the radical union was
304
01:23:20,263 --> 01:23:22,832
willing to go to war against
the capitalists but not
305
01:23:22,966 --> 01:23:24,199
the Germans.
306
01:23:24,334 --> 01:23:26,803
He is said to have claimed that
the Constitution of the United
307
01:23:26,937 --> 01:23:29,672
States was nothing more
than a scrap of paper, which
308
01:23:29,807 --> 01:23:32,108
can be torn up like any other,
when the authorities deem
309
01:23:32,242 --> 01:23:34,844
it necessary.
310
01:23:34,979 --> 01:23:36,579
All of the accounts
of the public speeches
311
01:23:36,713 --> 01:23:39,214
of the Agitator and all of the
accounts of the closed meetings
312
01:23:39,349 --> 01:23:42,885
of the union come from company
papers and company spies.
313
01:23:43,020 --> 01:23:46,021
Thus, company history
becomes official history.
314
01:23:46,156 --> 01:23:49,124
There are, however, texts
written by the Agitator.
315
01:23:49,259 --> 01:23:50,760
Perhaps, they more
accurately represent
316
01:23:50,894 --> 01:23:58,467
what he might have said
to the striking miners.
317
01:23:58,601 --> 01:25:40,402
[music playing]
318
01:25:40,537 --> 01:25:43,906
Within days, Anaconda seeks
to silence the Agitator by use
319
01:25:44,041 --> 01:25:46,409
of the Espionage Act, but
discovers that he cannot be
320
01:25:46,543 --> 01:25:48,944
prosecuted under existing law.
321
01:25:49,078 --> 01:26:17,773
Company papers then
run the headline.
322
01:26:17,907 --> 01:26:37,159
[music playing]
323
01:26:37,293 --> 01:26:41,129
It is the early morning
hours of August 1, 1917.
324
01:26:41,264 --> 01:26:45,567
Anaconda fulfills its
prophecies of violence.
325
01:26:45,702 --> 01:26:48,370
Informants reveal where
the Agitator can be found.
326
01:26:48,505 --> 01:26:50,139
He sleeps among the
workers in a boarding
327
01:26:50,273 --> 01:26:53,743
house known as the Steel Block.
328
01:26:53,877 --> 01:26:57,947
Six masked men emerge
from a large black car.
329
01:26:58,081 --> 01:27:01,017
They enter the boarding house
and awaken the landlord.
330
01:27:01,151 --> 01:27:04,386
They say, "We are officers,
and we want Little."
331
01:27:04,521 --> 01:27:07,456
The landlord points
towards room 32.
332
01:27:07,590 --> 01:27:09,324
The door is kicked in.
333
01:27:09,459 --> 01:27:12,260
The Agitator is dragged
to the waiting car.
334
01:27:12,395 --> 01:27:16,432
He remains silent and
offers minimal resistance.
335
01:27:16,566 --> 01:27:18,167
Still dressed in
his underwear, he
336
01:27:18,301 --> 01:27:21,603
is tied to the
bumper of the car.
337
01:27:21,738 --> 01:27:23,706
The car then drives to
the outskirts of the city,
338
01:27:23,840 --> 01:27:47,462
dragging the Agitator
the full distance.
339
01:27:47,597 --> 01:27:52,434
Bruises on his skull indicate
that he was beaten severely.
340
01:27:52,569 --> 01:27:54,971
Before being hanged
from a railroad trestle,
341
01:27:55,105 --> 01:27:57,172
a placard is pinned
to his underwear.
342
01:27:57,306 --> 01:27:59,174
It bears the
inscription, others take
343
01:27:59,308 --> 01:28:06,182
notice-- first and
last warning-- 3-7-77.
344
01:28:06,316 --> 01:28:09,017
The numbers are said to date
from the territorial era
345
01:28:09,151 --> 01:28:11,787
and to represent
vigilante justice.
346
01:28:11,922 --> 01:28:13,555
They are the
dimensions of a Montana
347
01:28:13,690 --> 01:28:20,662
grave-- three feet wide by seven
feet long by 77 inches deep.
348
01:28:20,797 --> 01:28:24,133
The Agitator had come to Butte
to speak to the striking miners
349
01:28:24,268 --> 01:28:27,569
and to describe an image of
a different kind of world.
350
01:28:27,704 --> 01:28:32,174
He is lynched by
persons still unknown.
351
01:28:32,309 --> 01:28:34,710
All that we know of Frank
Little's time in Butte and all
352
01:28:34,844 --> 01:28:36,311
that we know
regarding his murder,
353
01:28:36,446 --> 01:28:39,682
comes from company
papers and company spies.
354
01:28:39,816 --> 01:28:45,788
Thus, official history
is company history.
355
01:28:45,922 --> 01:28:48,390
It is the aftermath
of the murder.
356
01:28:48,524 --> 01:28:50,459
As the Agitator is
laid to rest, the town
357
01:28:50,594 --> 01:28:54,296
is suffocating under a constant
threat of escalating violence.
358
01:28:54,430 --> 01:28:57,266
Some say every man, woman,
and child in the country
359
01:28:57,400 --> 01:28:59,701
knows who perpetrated the crime.
360
01:28:59,836 --> 01:29:04,840
Some say the Indians of Montana
are again rising in rebellion.
361
01:29:04,974 --> 01:29:06,642
Some say, good work.
362
01:29:06,776 --> 01:29:13,849
Let them continue to hang
every IWW in the state.
363
01:29:13,984 --> 01:29:17,486
As many as 8,000 people march in
the largest funeral procession
364
01:29:17,620 --> 01:29:19,822
in the history of the town.
365
01:29:19,956 --> 01:29:22,157
The coroner's jury reports
that the Agitator was
366
01:29:22,291 --> 01:29:24,760
murdered by persons unknown.
367
01:29:24,894 --> 01:29:28,030
No one is ever
arrested for the crime.
368
01:29:28,165 --> 01:29:30,766
All of the documents relating
to the murder, including
369
01:29:30,900 --> 01:29:36,072
the coroner's reports
themselves, have disappeared.
370
01:29:36,206 --> 01:29:37,840
It is said that the
murder was carried out
371
01:29:37,974 --> 01:29:41,076
to provoke the
miners into violence.
372
01:29:41,211 --> 01:29:43,178
It is said that the
authorities sought a pretext
373
01:29:43,312 --> 01:29:45,814
for the imposition
of martial law.
374
01:29:45,949 --> 01:29:48,183
Among the striking miners
and their supporters,
375
01:29:48,317 --> 01:29:51,087
no violence is seen
or is reported.
376
01:29:51,221 --> 01:29:55,257
Nonetheless, martial law
is declared in Butte.
377
01:29:55,391 --> 01:29:57,760
Leaders of the radical
union are arrested.
378
01:29:57,894 --> 01:29:59,695
With the assistance of
the occupying forces,
379
01:29:59,829 --> 01:30:04,199
the strike is crushed, and
thus, the future of the town
380
01:30:04,333 --> 01:30:47,910
is nearly settled.
381
01:30:48,044 --> 01:30:51,046
Did the workers of Butte support
the ideas of Frank Little?
382
01:30:51,181 --> 01:30:55,217
This is difficult to say,
but consider the following.
383
01:30:55,352 --> 01:30:57,219
Little was one of
many union organizers
384
01:30:57,354 --> 01:31:00,889
who came to Butte during
the strife of 1917,
385
01:31:01,024 --> 01:31:02,624
but he was the only
outside organizer
386
01:31:02,759 --> 01:31:04,693
invited to address
large public gatherings
387
01:31:04,827 --> 01:31:07,796
of the striking miners
and their supporters.
388
01:31:07,931 --> 01:31:10,666
On both occasions, he
spoke publicly in Butte.
389
01:31:10,800 --> 01:31:12,735
It is reported that more
than 6,000 people were
390
01:31:12,869 --> 01:31:14,870
present to hear his remarks.
391
01:31:15,004 --> 01:31:17,906
Further, Frank Little was
the only outside organizer
392
01:31:18,041 --> 01:31:20,976
allowed to attend and to speak
at closed meetings of the Metal
393
01:31:21,110 --> 01:31:22,911
Mine Workers' Union.
394
01:31:23,046 --> 01:31:27,015
Finally, Frank Little's funeral
was and remains the largest
395
01:31:27,150 --> 01:31:30,152
funeral in Butte history
with as many as 8,000 people
396
01:31:30,286 --> 01:31:32,321
participating.
397
01:31:32,456 --> 01:31:37,058
Did the workers of Butte support
the ideas of Frank Little?
398
01:31:37,192 --> 01:34:45,547
[music playing]
399
01:34:45,681 --> 01:34:47,115
The murder of the
Agitator becomes
400
01:34:47,250 --> 01:34:50,785
a pretext for expanded violence
against the radical union.
401
01:34:50,920 --> 01:34:54,155
First, the union hall is
raided, and the local leaders
402
01:34:54,289 --> 01:34:55,924
of the union are jailed.
403
01:34:56,058 --> 01:34:58,360
Then 15 members of
the radical union
404
01:34:58,495 --> 01:35:01,963
are shot while picketing
along Anaconda Road.
405
01:35:02,098 --> 01:35:05,033
But these local acts
are only a prelude.
406
01:35:05,168 --> 01:35:08,036
First, the Montana
Espionage Act is rewritten
407
01:35:08,171 --> 01:35:10,305
into the Montana Sedition Act.
408
01:35:10,440 --> 01:35:13,008
Then the Montana
Sedition Act is rewritten
409
01:35:13,142 --> 01:35:15,844
to become the
National Sedition Act.
410
01:35:15,978 --> 01:35:18,947
According to the new laws,
members of the radical union
411
01:35:19,081 --> 01:35:21,150
or similar organizations
can be arrested
412
01:35:21,284 --> 01:35:24,252
and deported as enemy aliens.
413
01:35:24,387 --> 01:35:27,489
Strikes that interfere with the
war drive are made criminal.
414
01:35:27,624 --> 01:35:30,625
Sedition is defined as
uttering disloyal words
415
01:35:30,759 --> 01:35:32,927
and is made criminal.
416
01:35:33,062 --> 01:35:37,098
Thought, belief, and
association are made criminal.
417
01:35:37,233 --> 01:35:40,802
Mass arrests and deportations
begin almost immediately.
418
01:35:40,936 --> 01:35:43,205
Mere weeks after the
murder of Little in Butte,
419
01:35:43,339 --> 01:35:46,542
the radical union is targeted
in a massive indictment.
420
01:35:46,676 --> 01:35:49,277
As if to assist us in
connecting the dots,
421
01:35:49,412 --> 01:35:51,880
though Frank Little is
already cold in the ground,
422
01:35:52,014 --> 01:35:55,484
his name is included
in the indictment.
423
01:35:55,618 --> 01:35:58,753
More than 100 Wobbly organizers
are convicted of espionage
424
01:35:58,888 --> 01:36:00,655
and sentenced from
five to 20 years
425
01:36:00,789 --> 01:36:02,824
in the federal penitentiary.
426
01:36:02,958 --> 01:36:05,494
In the following year,
the Palmer raids begin,
427
01:36:05,628 --> 01:36:08,096
and the repressions
become more acute.
428
01:36:08,231 --> 01:36:11,433
In January of 1920 alone,
more than 10,000 members
429
01:36:11,568 --> 01:36:15,337
of radical organizations are
arrested in raids on 70 cities.
430
01:36:15,471 --> 01:36:19,107
Hundreds of foreign born
members are summarily deported.
431
01:36:19,242 --> 01:36:21,843
American members face
trial, massive fines,
432
01:36:21,977 --> 01:36:23,945
and lengthy prison terms.
433
01:36:24,080 --> 01:36:25,747
Should we still
miss the obvious?
434
01:36:25,881 --> 01:36:27,882
History offers us a
clue as to the nature
435
01:36:28,017 --> 01:36:30,052
of the repression set into
motion in the hard rock
436
01:36:30,186 --> 01:36:32,387
mines of the American West.
437
01:36:32,522 --> 01:36:34,222
Among those named
in the indictments
438
01:36:34,357 --> 01:36:36,725
and later sentenced to
five years in Leavenworth
439
01:36:36,859 --> 01:36:45,767
is a man named Joseph McCarthy.
440
01:36:45,901 --> 01:36:47,702
That which we call
McCarthyism existed
441
01:36:47,836 --> 01:36:50,839
both before and
after its namesake.
442
01:36:50,973 --> 01:36:52,841
Its sharpest effects
were felt in the arenas
443
01:36:52,976 --> 01:36:56,512
of public discourse, in the
schools, and in the theaters.
444
01:36:56,646 --> 01:36:58,913
It was and is,
first and foremost,
445
01:36:59,048 --> 01:37:01,016
an impulse towards the
suppression of ideas
446
01:37:01,150 --> 01:37:10,024
themselves.
447
01:37:10,159 --> 01:37:13,395
That which we call
McCarthyism is with us still.
448
01:37:13,529 --> 01:37:15,530
It is present in the
mutilated landscapes
449
01:37:15,665 --> 01:37:19,400
of our industrial past and
in the impoverished discourse
450
01:37:19,534 --> 01:37:22,204
regarding our future.
451
01:37:22,338 --> 01:37:25,574
It is 1917, and the
nation has for some time
452
01:37:25,708 --> 01:37:28,276
been a volcano on the
point of eruption.
453
01:37:28,411 --> 01:37:32,213
The murder of the Agitator
proves to be the flaming torch.
454
01:37:32,348 --> 01:37:35,784
It now seems clear-- the
journey towards McCarthyism
455
01:37:35,918 --> 01:38:36,111
passes along Anaconda Road.
456
01:38:36,245 --> 01:38:39,281
And in this manner, the
black heart of Montana
457
01:38:39,415 --> 01:38:42,417
becomes the black heart
of the nation, or to put
458
01:38:42,552 --> 01:38:44,686
it another way,
in a rare instance
459
01:38:44,821 --> 01:38:47,555
of a slogan made
literal, an injury to one
460
01:38:47,689 --> 01:39:00,869
becomes an injury to all.
461
01:39:01,003 --> 01:40:30,124
[music playing]
462
01:40:30,259 --> 01:40:34,028
It is 1951, the
height of McCarthyism.
463
01:40:34,163 --> 01:40:35,731
The crime novelist
Dashiell Hammett
464
01:40:35,865 --> 01:40:38,966
is jailed for refusing
to name names.
465
01:40:39,101 --> 01:40:41,636
He had once served as
an agent of Anaconda.
466
01:40:41,771 --> 01:40:44,606
Now he is labeled
a traitorous red.
467
01:40:44,740 --> 01:40:47,075
His closest friend, the
playwright Lillian Hellman,
468
01:40:47,209 --> 01:40:50,178
later explains.
469
01:40:50,313 --> 01:40:53,214
"During his Pinkerton days, an
officer of the Anaconda Copper
470
01:40:53,349 --> 01:40:58,886
Company had offered Hammett
$5,000 to kill Frank Little.
471
01:40:59,021 --> 01:41:01,022
It seems one can
date Hammett's belief
472
01:41:01,157 --> 01:41:05,593
that he was living in a corrupt
society from Little's murder.
473
01:41:05,728 --> 01:41:08,730
In time, he came to the
conclusion that nothing less
474
01:41:08,865 --> 01:41:11,532
than a revolution could
wipe out the corruption.
475
01:41:11,667 --> 01:41:14,936
Sometimes in complex minds,
it is the plainest experience
476
01:41:15,071 --> 01:41:22,810
that speeds the wheels that
have already begun to move.
477
01:41:22,944 --> 01:41:28,783
[music playing]
478
01:41:28,917 --> 01:41:31,252
It is November, 1995.
479
01:41:31,387 --> 01:41:37,692
A large flock of migrating geese
is overtaken by a sudden storm.
480
01:41:37,827 --> 01:41:40,194
In these circumstances,
it is the instinct
481
01:41:40,329 --> 01:41:50,104
of geese to set down on
the nearest body of water.
482
01:41:50,239 --> 01:42:00,114
Anaconda has long since
abandoned the town.
483
01:42:00,249 --> 01:42:04,586
Butte was once called the
richest hill on Earth.
484
01:42:04,720 --> 01:42:07,054
It is estimated that
at least $25 billion
485
01:42:07,189 --> 01:42:15,463
have been extracted
from the mines Butte.
486
01:42:15,598 --> 01:42:31,679
When Anaconda fled, it carried
those billions with them.
487
01:42:31,814 --> 01:42:34,749
Likewise, it took the
thousands of jobs once created
488
01:42:34,883 --> 01:42:52,233
by the mines.
489
01:42:52,367 --> 01:42:55,636
But the company did
leave something.
490
01:42:55,771 --> 01:42:58,306
The town now has the distinction
of being the most polluted site
491
01:42:58,440 --> 01:43:01,309
in the nation.
492
01:43:01,444 --> 01:43:06,380
The ecological catastrophe is
embodied by the Berkeley Pit.
493
01:43:06,515 --> 01:43:09,384
Though it was once the world's
largest open pit copper mine,
494
01:43:09,518 --> 01:43:13,521
the pit now lies unused.
495
01:43:13,656 --> 01:43:15,490
In the last years
of its operation,
496
01:43:15,624 --> 01:43:18,693
it quite literally began
to consume the town.
497
01:43:18,828 --> 01:43:20,227
Where the pit now
stands, there were
498
01:43:20,362 --> 01:43:23,631
neighborhoods of modest
homes and a beloved park.
499
01:43:23,766 --> 01:43:28,736
Now they're gone, and the pit
sits idle like an open wound.
500
01:43:28,871 --> 01:43:33,475
Slowly but surely the pit
is filling with water.
501
01:43:33,609 --> 01:43:35,242
The so-called Lake
Berkeley is now
502
01:43:35,377 --> 01:43:37,312
the largest body of
severely contaminated water
503
01:43:37,446 --> 01:43:41,382
in the United States.
504
01:43:41,517 --> 01:43:45,320
Standing nearly a mile wide
and more than 900 feet deep,
505
01:43:45,455 --> 01:43:50,558
the water is laced with copper,
cadmium, zinc, nickel, lead,
506
01:43:50,693 --> 01:43:53,961
arsenic, and sulfates in
concentrations several
507
01:43:54,095 --> 01:43:55,896
thousands of times
more than most
508
01:43:56,031 --> 01:43:59,200
found in uncontaminated water.
509
01:43:59,334 --> 01:44:02,904
The pH level of the
water is around 2.5,
510
01:44:03,039 --> 01:44:08,076
roughly comparable
to battery acid.
511
01:44:08,211 --> 01:44:11,346
There is now a proposal,
only partly ironic,
512
01:44:11,481 --> 01:44:14,983
to have Butte named the First
National Environmental Disaster
513
01:44:15,116 --> 01:44:29,530
Monument.
514
01:44:29,665 --> 01:44:33,968
Yet despite everything
the town endures,
515
01:44:34,103 --> 01:45:12,273
many of Butte's inhabitants
have been forced to move on.
516
01:45:12,407 --> 01:45:15,910
But a resilient few
have chosen to remain.
517
01:45:16,045 --> 01:46:36,524
Like people everywhere,
they labor, they play,
518
01:46:36,658 --> 01:46:56,911
they do what they
must to survive.
519
01:46:57,046 --> 01:46:58,713
The town's residents
continue to dream
520
01:46:58,847 --> 01:47:02,283
of a different kind of
future, but sometimes, they're
521
01:47:02,417 --> 01:47:04,451
still forced to
contend with the past
522
01:47:04,586 --> 01:47:09,957
and with the predator that
left their town for dead.
523
01:47:10,092 --> 01:47:13,995
For example, it is said that
until recently, cats could not
524
01:47:14,129 --> 01:47:15,930
survive in Butte,
because the dirt they
525
01:47:16,065 --> 01:47:18,900
cleaned from their fur
was poisoned with arsenic.
526
01:47:19,034 --> 01:47:22,803
For example, it
is November, 1995.
527
01:47:22,938 --> 01:47:25,539
The geese have begun
their seasonal migration.
528
01:47:25,674 --> 01:47:29,443
A large flock is overtaken
by a sudden storm.
529
01:47:29,578 --> 01:47:31,579
In these circumstances,
it is the instinct
530
01:47:31,713 --> 01:47:37,551
of geese to set down on
the nearest body of water.
531
01:47:37,686 --> 01:47:41,256
The morning following
the storm, 342 geese
532
01:47:41,390 --> 01:47:44,892
are discovered floating
dead in the water.
533
01:47:45,027 --> 01:47:47,895
The carcasses are found
with their feathers matted.
534
01:47:48,030 --> 01:47:50,264
They are blistered with
lesions and are suffering
535
01:47:50,398 --> 01:47:52,200
from a range of
internal injuries,
536
01:47:52,334 --> 01:47:56,570
including corroded
esophagi and trachea.
537
01:47:56,705 --> 01:47:58,339
Their livers and
kidneys are bloated
538
01:47:58,474 --> 01:48:07,515
with toxic levels of copper,
manganese, zinc, and cadmium.
539
01:48:07,649 --> 01:48:09,783
The predator has
itself been consumed,
540
01:48:09,918 --> 01:48:16,757
and a new company, Arco, now
owns what is left of the mines,
541
01:48:16,892 --> 01:48:19,527
but some things haven't
changed, and representatives
542
01:48:19,661 --> 01:48:21,395
of the new company
assure residents
543
01:48:21,529 --> 01:48:24,265
that the water is safe.
544
01:48:24,400 --> 01:48:31,939
They are certain the geese died
because of something they ate.
545
01:48:32,074 --> 01:48:33,474
Others have
attributed the deaths
546
01:48:33,608 --> 01:48:39,347
to a new phenomenon
called pit effect.
547
01:48:39,482 --> 01:48:43,284
Dashiell Hammett had called
his fictional town Poisonville.
548
01:48:43,419 --> 01:48:48,389
He couldn't guess how it
would resound 70 years later.
549
01:48:48,523 --> 01:48:50,591
The history of
the events of 1917
550
01:48:50,725 --> 01:48:52,893
is difficult to reassemble.
551
01:48:53,028 --> 01:48:56,331
Much of the evidence has been
destroyed or has disappeared.
552
01:48:56,465 --> 01:48:58,099
This includes all of
the files pertaining
553
01:48:58,233 --> 01:49:01,135
to the murder of Frank
Little, the police dossier,
554
01:49:01,269 --> 01:49:03,871
and the coroner's report.
555
01:49:04,006 --> 01:49:07,041
On order of the federal courts,
all of the documents pertaining
556
01:49:07,176 --> 01:49:09,610
to the mass arrests and
prosecutions of the leadership
557
01:49:09,744 --> 01:49:12,579
of the IWW were burned.
558
01:49:12,714 --> 01:49:14,882
Dashiell Hammett's role in
the murder of Frank Little
559
01:49:15,017 --> 01:49:17,751
likewise remains an enigma.
560
01:49:17,886 --> 01:49:20,255
All of the documents pertaining
to the role of the Pinkerton
561
01:49:20,389 --> 01:49:22,556
Detective Agency in the
sabotage of the labor
562
01:49:22,691 --> 01:49:25,593
movement, including the
case reports of Hammett,
563
01:49:25,727 --> 01:49:28,129
were said to be lost in a fire.
564
01:49:28,263 --> 01:49:30,231
Much of the evidence
has thus been destroyed
565
01:49:30,366 --> 01:49:38,505
or has disappeared--
much, but not all.
566
01:49:38,640 --> 01:49:40,942
As the geese helped to
demonstrate, history,
567
01:49:41,076 --> 01:49:44,845
in this case, cannot be
so easily expurgated.
568
01:49:44,980 --> 01:49:47,614
In an act reminiscent
of a mass suicide,
569
01:49:47,749 --> 01:49:49,851
the geese hurled themselves
into the open wound
570
01:49:49,985 --> 01:49:55,856
in the heart of the town.
571
01:49:55,991 --> 01:49:58,626
Perhaps using the
only manner they knew,
572
01:49:58,760 --> 01:50:00,194
these creatures were
trying to tell us
573
01:50:00,329 --> 01:50:04,665
something, because it seemed
to have escaped our notice.
574
01:50:04,799 --> 01:50:07,301
They were directing us
to the scene of a crime.
575
01:50:07,435 --> 01:50:14,776
[geese honking]
576
01:50:14,910 --> 01:51:41,729
[music playing]
577
01:51:41,863 --> 01:51:44,165
The Berkeley Pit,
started in 1955,
578
01:51:44,299 --> 01:51:47,534
was a large truck-operated
open pit copper mine
579
01:51:47,669 --> 01:51:50,104
until mining closed in 1982.
580
01:51:50,238 --> 01:51:53,641
By 1980, nearly one and a
half billion tons of material
581
01:51:53,776 --> 01:51:57,111
had been removed from the
pit, including more than 290
582
01:51:57,245 --> 01:51:59,180
million tons of copper ore.
583
01:51:59,314 --> 01:52:03,284
The pit is 7,000 feet
long, 5,600 feet wide,
584
01:52:03,418 --> 01:52:07,421
and 1,600 feet from the high
wall on the north side just
585
01:52:07,555 --> 01:52:09,023
below the Kelley Mines.
586
01:52:09,157 --> 01:52:11,358
During underground mining,
water from the mineshaft
587
01:52:11,492 --> 01:52:12,727
was pumped to the surface.
588
01:52:12,862 --> 01:52:16,097
When Anaconda shut down its
underground operations in 1982,
589
01:52:16,231 --> 01:52:18,666
the pumping system
was abandoned.
590
01:52:18,801 --> 01:52:21,535
Ground water began to rise
through the several thousand
591
01:52:21,670 --> 01:52:25,139
miles of interconnected tunnels,
many combing the Butte Hill,
592
01:52:25,273 --> 01:52:26,741
seeping into the pit.
593
01:52:26,876 --> 01:52:29,844
The pit waters the city due
to the contact of the water
594
01:52:29,978 --> 01:52:31,378
with mineralized ore zones.
595
01:52:31,513 --> 01:52:34,315
To keep birds from landing on
the water in the pit, players,
596
01:52:34,449 --> 01:52:37,518
shell crackers, and electronic
noisemakers are being used.
597
01:52:37,653 --> 01:52:41,688
The pit water at the moment
is about 950 feet deep.
598
01:52:41,823 --> 01:52:43,123
Toward the mountains
on your right
599
01:52:43,258 --> 01:52:45,759
is the continental pit, which is
being mined seven days a week,
600
01:52:45,894 --> 01:52:49,263
24 hours a day for
copper and [inaudible].
601
01:52:49,397 --> 01:52:51,733
Welcome to Butte.
Distributor: Icarus Films
Length: 53 minutes
Date: 2003
Genre: Expository
Language: English
Grade: 9-12, College, Adult
Color/BW:
/
Closed Captioning: Available
Interactive Transcript: Available
Existing customers, please log in to view this film.
New to Docuseek? Register to request a quote.