Argues that overpopulation is not the real cause of poverty in India or…
Life - Untouchable?

- Description
- Reviews
- Citation
- Cataloging
- Transcript
If you are not affiliated with a college or university, and are interested in watching this film, please register as an individual and login to rent this film. Already registered? Login to rent this film.
Veerasamy takes in washing for his living. He lives in a small village in southern India where all the inhabitants are dalits -- outcasts or 'untouchables' as they're known in India.
But even among the dalits, there are divisions, and Veerasamy belongs to the lowest scale of the hierarchy. The only payment he receives for back-breaking work, washing and steaming and drying the village's laundry, is to receive the left-overs from their meals to feed his small family.
Discrimination based on caste membership has been, theoretically, illegal since India first gained independence in 1947. But, as this Life program from Danish director Poul Kjar shows only too plainly, it's an accepted part of everyday life across the continent.
Whole families of dalit people exist effectively as bonded or slave laborers, cutting up rocks with their bare hands in a Tamil Nadu quarry. Eight-year-old children -- prized for their docility, hard work and dexterity -- work ten 12-hour days in India's silk factories.
There are an estimated 100 million child laborers in India. Human Rights organizations are now, finally, taking up the dalits' cause and, as Archbishop Emeritus Desmond Tutu urges in the introduction to the film, calling for the end of a system of discrimination as heinous as the former apartheid system he and his generation fought against in South Africa.
'Despite human rights reforms, this film emphasizes that the scourge of 'untouchability' remains an abominable blight on the Indian social landscape.' Timothy McGettigan, Professor of Sociology, University of Southern Colorado
Citation
Main credits
Halding, Esben (film producer)
Kjar, Poul (film director)
Bradshaw, Steve (commentator)
Other credits
Camera, Poul Kjar, Scott Jennison; music, The Definitive Break; editors, Marie-Louise Bordingaard, Damien Rea.
Distributor subjects
Anthropology; Child Labor; Developing World; Economics; Ethics; Geography; Global Issues; Globalization; History; Human Rights; Humanities; India; International Studies; Labor and Work Issues; Social Justice; Sociology; United NationsKeywords
00:09.579 --> 00:15.439
Previously on Life, put people back into the
picture, and make the global economy work for them.
00:15.880 --> 00:18.719
People's voices are going to become more and more
important.
00:18.889 --> 00:23.049
There are some who win, but there are more and
more who are being left behind.
00:24.069 --> 00:28.590
The opportunity to get a job, the opportunity
to get into a situation where you can negotiate,
00:28.989 --> 00:33.240
where you can build your standard of living, is
something that very many people want.
01:04.360 --> 01:08.480
I want to tell you a little about the plight of
the Dalits.
01:09.849 --> 01:16.629
A community of 200 million fellow human beings
in
01:16.629 --> 01:20.519
India.
The so-called untouchables.
01:20.809 --> 01:27.180
They suffer from discrimination under the caste
system, which has
01:27.180 --> 01:28.750
dehumanised them.
01:29.169 --> 01:35.769
You will see in the episode of Life, what it
01:35.769 --> 01:38.889
means to be born into this community.
01:40.099 --> 01:45.930
India was in the forefront of the struggle
against apartheid.
01:47.529 --> 01:51.589
We believe that the Indian people
01:52.300 --> 01:59.010
would want to end the scourge which is a blot.
02:00.239 --> 02:03.269
For humanity in this new millennium.
02:03.800 --> 02:05.199
Let us work together.
02:06.080 --> 02:12.759
To end it, India
02:12.759 --> 02:18.600
today has nuclear weapons, a computer industry,
and its very own Hollywood-style film industry.
02:18.970 --> 02:22.630
It has an extremely rich upper class and a huge
middle class.
02:23.600 --> 02:30.429
But it also has 200 million poor outcasts or
Dalits, stigmatised from the day they are born
02:30.600 --> 02:32.610
and who suffer massive discrimination.
02:43.110 --> 02:47.529
Viraami lives in a small village in southern
India.
02:47.529 --> 02:51.050
All the inhabitants here are outcasts.
02:51.250 --> 02:55.880
Viraami's job consists of doing the washing
for the 19 families in the village.
03:05.020 --> 03:11.990
No.
When
03:11.990 --> 03:16.139
I go and collect the laundry, I ask why we have
to do this.
03:16.589 --> 03:19.500
We have to do it because we belong to this
caste.
03:20.070 --> 03:23.929
People say we will be reborn, and that's the
reason why we must do it.
03:27.360 --> 03:33.929
Ma.
And the outcasts themselves are subdivided into
03:33.929 --> 03:37.000
further groupings.
The washer men and women belong to the very
03:37.000 --> 03:38.839
lowest scale of this hierarchy.
03:39.169 --> 03:44.369
The only payment Viraami receives for his work
are leftovers from the meals other inhabitants
03:44.369 --> 03:46.350
in the village have already eaten.
03:50.289 --> 03:57.190
Very few people usually say that it causes you
no harm to do this.
03:57.190 --> 04:01.139
Kind of job.
They say that in the end you will go to heaven.
04:01.139 --> 04:02.619
For having done this.
04:03.309 --> 04:06.869
Do you believe that?
One would have to die to find out.
04:08.419 --> 04:11.039
I, oh.
04:16.269 --> 04:19.459
Mira Sami's family have been washermen for
generations.
04:19.760 --> 04:23.339
Coming from the lowest caste in Indian society,
it's their destiny.
04:26.320 --> 04:29.230
His wife Desam and their three children help him do
the work.
04:30.339 --> 04:31.339
If we had our own land, we would be happy.
04:37.929 --> 04:43.850
We would not depend on others, but we don't
have our own place, and we have to be very
04:43.850 --> 04:46.079
servile and obey orders.
04:47.089 --> 04:51.239
If we had our own land, we would work hard and
do something else.
04:51.450 --> 04:56.690
For instance, we could open a fruit shop, but
we are dependent on others,
04:56.720 --> 04:59.600
and that's the reason why we have to live this
way.
05:01.989 --> 05:05.119
No.
If you are rich, it's no problem.
05:06.160 --> 05:12.589
Discrimination based on caste has been
prohibited by law since India first gained its
05:12.589 --> 05:18.609
independence in 1947, but the 200 million
outcasts in the country are still being
05:18.609 --> 05:21.200
oppressed, still discriminated against.
05:21.809 --> 05:25.929
Many have left their fingerprints on contracts
which make them indebted for the rest of their
05:25.929 --> 05:28.369
lives to people from higher castes.
05:29.459 --> 05:34.660
Often too, the outcasts or Dalits are caught up
in working conditions that are more like
05:34.660 --> 05:35.660
slavery.
05:41.820 --> 05:43.649
This is very dangerous work.
05:43.859 --> 05:47.250
You can hardly avoid being hurt, but we have to
work.
05:47.750 --> 05:51.179
The stones cut me on both my arms and my legs.
05:51.380 --> 05:57.980
Look at the scars on my legs and here, but we
tolerate it because we are fighting for our
05:57.980 --> 06:00.450
lives.
We are fighting the grim reaper.
06:00.619 --> 06:03.730
It is a hard and dangerously deadly job.
06:10.720 --> 06:13.630
Mr.
Kumar and his family are bonded labourers.
06:13.959 --> 06:16.070
They owe money to the owner of the quarry.
06:19.459 --> 06:23.570
During the rainy season, the stones are buried
under the soil,
06:23.859 --> 06:26.690
and my manager says we must dig them out.
06:28.660 --> 06:32.260
We have to dig out the stones and cut them to
pieces.
06:32.380 --> 06:34.899
If we don't, we receive no payment.
06:36.269 --> 06:42.119
I can't go anywhere else because we have been
paid in advance,
06:43.410 --> 06:50.049
so he would claim his money back before we
could go anywhere.
06:50.049 --> 06:53.239
If we only knew how to make
more money, we could choose to do something else.
06:57.130 --> 07:00.709
We have to work like slaves to survive.
07:01.799 --> 07:04.790
We have to work like slaves to earn our daily
bread.
07:11.059 --> 07:12.059
In
07:18.529 --> 07:19.529
Yeah
07:27.529 --> 07:31.609
Asan is 12.
He's the son of outcast parents and has worked
07:31.609 --> 07:33.720
in the silk industry since he was 8.
07:34.290 --> 07:38.119
He's just one of approximately 100 million
child labourers in India.
07:39.649 --> 07:43.869
I work 10 hours a day from 7:30 a.m.
To 6 p.m.
07:44.489 --> 07:48.279
Without lunch and including lunch.
07:48.570 --> 07:50.519
That makes 10 hours.
07:51.029 --> 07:52.570
And you work how many days a week?
07:52.779 --> 07:56.190
All 7 days of the week.
You don't have a day off on Sundays?
07:56.450 --> 08:00.619
No.
You don't have Sundays.
08:00.980 --> 08:04.579
No, but we get the day off when there is a
celebration of some kind,
08:04.739 --> 08:07.100
for instance, Deepavali or Amai.
08:08.375 --> 08:11.045
We have 10 days off for the harvest festival.
08:12.334 --> 08:13.825
Do you like working in a weaving mill?
08:15.654 --> 08:18.605
Yes, sure.
Once you've learnt it, it's not difficult.
08:18.855 --> 08:22.445
They only go on at you in the beginning until
you have learnt it.
08:25.859 --> 08:27.609
Then it's fun to work alone.
08:31.049 --> 08:34.109
In the West, there's been a lot of publicity
about child labour,
08:34.320 --> 08:38.989
and the owners of big textile factories are
wary of giving interviews to human rights
08:38.989 --> 08:43.789
organisations or Western media, but the owners
of small weaving mills are not so defensive.
08:44.679 --> 08:46.710
Do the children come from poor families?
08:47.000 --> 08:49.309
Yes, indeed, all of them.
08:50.830 --> 08:53.405
Rich people
don't work in this industry.
08:56.174 --> 09:00.335
Are the children Dalits?
Yes, it's hard work,
09:00.375 --> 09:04.645
isn't it?
Yes, you have to be alert all the time.
09:04.934 --> 09:10.044
It's not like driving an ox cart or working in
the rice fields.
09:15.549 --> 09:22.419
I don't care about my next life.
If I
09:22.419 --> 09:26.409
can't be happy together with my children in
this life,
09:26.619 --> 09:29.010
how can I then dream about the next life?
09:29.780 --> 09:35.369
I can't send them to school or give them a
happy life or give them enough food.
09:40.820 --> 09:43.059
Why am I in this unhappy situation?
09:44.090 --> 09:50.359
When I was a child, I wasn't happy, but now I
see that my children aren't any better off.
09:50.690 --> 09:52.760
Is this their lot in life?
10:06.000 --> 10:12.020
The Indian caste system stems from Hinduism,
and about 80% of all Indians are Hindus.
10:12.450 --> 10:17.400
If you're an outcast, a Dalit, it's because
you've led a bad life in an earlier incarnation.
10:17.530 --> 10:20.000
This is your fate, and you have to put up with
it.
10:20.809 --> 10:25.210
According to Hinduism, man has more than one
life, and if a person behaves well in his
10:25.210 --> 10:28.289
present life, he can be reincarnated into a
better one.
10:29.159 --> 10:33.159
Prabhakaran is a Brahmin priest and belongs to
the highest caste.
10:35.510 --> 10:38.390
Each caste has its particular kind of work.
10:38.679 --> 10:40.869
Take me.
I'm a priest.
10:41.239 --> 10:46.400
I couldn't carry out the work of a carpenter or
a bricklayer.
10:46.580 --> 10:49.469
Every person has his own trade.
10:52.400 --> 10:56.400
Oh, Navid.
It
11:03.109 --> 11:08.919
it.
Yeah.
11:12.770 --> 11:13.770
My
11:20.479 --> 11:24.190
Mani is the owner of the quarry.
He visits the stonemasons every day.
11:32.349 --> 11:36.059
We work, but the owner doesn't pay us
sufficiently.
11:36.299 --> 11:43.270
Prices go up, and so we want higher wages, but
we're told that first we
11:43.270 --> 11:45.940
have to work off what we have been paid for.
11:46.229 --> 11:50.099
When we have paid our debt, we are free to go
somewhere else.
11:50.390 --> 11:52.380
There is no other way out.
11:52.710 --> 11:56.909
What else can we do?
We work like slaves, but where else can we find
11:56.909 --> 12:03.270
work?
That is why we stay here.
12:07.469 --> 12:09.299
I don't force them to stay.
12:09.510 --> 12:11.700
You can go and ask them yourself.
12:11.909 --> 12:15.409
I haven't forbidden them to go and work
somewhere else.
12:15.950 --> 12:18.340
They work here because they want to.
12:18.630 --> 12:20.469
They follow their hearts.
12:21.390 --> 12:23.090
How many of them have borrowed money from you?
12:23.669 --> 12:27.729
They don't borrow money.
They get their payment in advance.
12:28.419 --> 12:30.789
Has everyone received payment in advance? Yes.
12:31.020 --> 12:37.169
How much have they had in advance?
20,000 to ₹30,000, but they work for them.
12:37.419 --> 12:40.849
If you borrow 1000, you work for 1000.
12:41.590 --> 12:44.200
₹1000 is about $24.
12:45.609 --> 12:48.359
We get about 20 to ₹30 a day.
12:48.609 --> 12:53.479
After eight days' work, we receive about 100 to
₹150.
12:53.890 --> 12:58.640
Let's say we spend ₹50 on a bicycle, then there
is only 100 left.
13:00.289 --> 13:01.359
I have a big family.
13:01.580 --> 13:07.080
There are 5 mouths to feed, and 1 kg of rice
costs ₹10.
13:08.789 --> 13:12.070
A week's payment of ₹100 is about $2.40.
13:15.770 --> 13:19.440
Hinduism makes a distinction between clean and
unclean people.
13:19.609 --> 13:25.010
As outcasts, the Dalits are regarded as unclean,
while people within the caste system are
13:25.010 --> 13:28.419
considered clean.
Clean people must not touch unclean people.
13:28.609 --> 13:33.210
This is why many of India's 200 million
outcasts live in separate villages,
13:33.280 --> 13:37.450
and it's why the unclean Dalits are also known
as the Untouchables.
13:39.609 --> 13:44.400
Even if it is 12 at night and we have come all
the way to Madras by bus,
13:44.530 --> 13:49.640
we must take off our clothes and wash ourselves
before we enter the house.
13:49.929 --> 13:53.659
Outside, there are many people, and some of
them are unclean,
13:53.890 --> 13:56.440
but we have to be clean at all times.
13:56.690 --> 14:01.000
If you want to enter our house, you must wash
your feet first.
14:01.260 --> 14:05.159
Some might say, but we washed our feet before
putting on our shoes.
14:05.450 --> 14:07.359
Why must we then wash them again?
14:07.729 --> 14:10.150
But you have to wash them before entering.
14:16.080 --> 14:18.840
The outcasts come into the temple even when
they're not allowed.
14:19.159 --> 14:21.070
They can't understand why they're not allowed
in.
14:21.159 --> 14:25.630
What's your view?
Even when we explain it to them,
14:25.799 --> 14:27.789
they won't understand and accept it.
14:28.000 --> 14:29.309
It's unbelievable.
14:29.520 --> 14:34.239
They say that they're cleaner than us.
They say that they doubt that I have washed
14:34.239 --> 14:37.830
myself in the morning.
I have holy ashes on my forehead,
14:38.039 --> 14:40.789
but they could just put on some of it too.
14:41.239 --> 14:42.950
They have this silly attitude.
14:43.650 --> 14:46.789
They refused to accept the situation exactly.
14:52.570 --> 14:59.460
It is our destiny to wash these things.
That's
14:59.460 --> 15:01.460
why we have to do this work.
15:02.140 --> 15:04.809
We wash the linen by hand and return it.
15:05.460 --> 15:09.640
Even linen used at childbirth and during
abortions.
15:14.419 --> 15:21.280
Uh-huh.
At the washerman's, the pre-washing
15:21.280 --> 15:26.200
is now finished and the family can eat the
leftovers which Darsan collected in a pot in
15:26.200 --> 15:28.119
the village and brought down to the river.
15:31.679 --> 15:37.530
I make the sherry in
15:41.190 --> 15:47.450
Eke the sherry, Bo they tummy.
15:52.479 --> 15:59.280
My wife also comes from a washerman's
15:59.280 --> 16:06.229
family.
They do the same work as we do, so we
16:06.229 --> 16:08.900
don't have family problems.
16:10.190 --> 16:14.580
If she was from another caste and if she
disagreed with me,
16:15.059 --> 16:16.900
she might regret marrying me.
16:18.710 --> 16:24.630
But she doesn't belong to another caste, so
there is no problem.
16:27.330 --> 16:31.789
The laundry has been steamed for one hour and
the family is ready for the big washing
16:31.789 --> 16:32.869
programme of the afternoon.
16:39.880 --> 16:44.390
I go to work because my family is poor, other
children are not poor,
16:44.479 --> 16:49.880
and their parents aren't sick, but I have to
work.
16:53.369 --> 16:59.280
If the boys fall ill, their parents ask me to
lend them ₹500.
17:00.210 --> 17:06.119
We also pay them an advance of ₹2000 to ₹5000
before they start working.
17:07.050 --> 17:09.680
If they have problems, we help them.
17:13.948 --> 17:19.119
It's Assan's responsibility to repay the
family's debt to the owner of the looms.
17:20.938 --> 17:27.458
We were paid ₹4000 in advance and they reduced
it by ₹200 every month.
17:27.479 --> 17:32.009
₹200 of ₹500.
17:33.959 --> 17:35.050
Do you get more than that?
17:35.479 --> 17:37.050
No, only ₹200.
17:37.400 --> 17:38.839
Yes, ₹200 only.
17:45.030 --> 17:48.979
We can't ever pay back our debts because when
we borrow ₹300,
17:48.989 --> 17:52.630
he writes down ₹400.
Maybe we will have to be here for the rest of
17:52.630 --> 17:55.020
our lives.
So you'll have to remain in slavery?
17:55.189 --> 18:01.650
Yes.
I
18:03.050 --> 18:07.430
Their children are the stonemason's only hope
of breaking their chains.
18:07.729 --> 18:11.949
With help from a local organisation, the
children are able to attend school a couple of
18:11.949 --> 18:13.160
hours every weekday.
18:13.550 --> 18:18.310
By learning to read, write and do arithmetic,
they'll be able to take the first steps towards
18:18.310 --> 18:19.500
changing their destiny.
18:20.310 --> 18:25.310
But it's a long and difficult road ahead and
one made harder by the repressive reactions of
18:25.310 --> 18:28.819
the authorities whenever the outcasts attempt
to protest.
18:39.880 --> 18:46.699
Before the outcasts didn't come here, but today
75% of those who do the cleaning
18:46.699 --> 18:48.670
here are outcasts.
18:49.119 --> 18:51.349
They also moved the statues around.
18:54.560 --> 18:55.979
But they work here.
18:56.489 --> 19:03.280
Formerly, when we were on our way to the temple,
the outcasts would step aside for us
19:03.280 --> 19:08.020
and take off their scarves and shoes in order
to pay their respect.
19:08.650 --> 19:10.880
Now they rub shoulders with us.
19:11.250 --> 19:15.729
They have changed.
We used to put things out for them outside
19:15.729 --> 19:22.260
which they would come and pick up, but now they
simply stretch out their hands and want us to
19:22.260 --> 19:27.689
put the things directly into their hands
because they say they're cleaner than us.
19:27.979 --> 19:30.410
They wash themselves twice a day.
19:31.380 --> 19:32.609
What do you think of that?
19:33.739 --> 19:35.849
I don't want to comment on that.
19:36.300 --> 19:37.959
It's very difficult.
19:38.880 --> 19:45.640
I don't speak to them and I don't give them
anything of
19:45.640 --> 19:50.170
that which you've been sacrificing when they
enter, I go out.
19:54.459 --> 19:55.459
Ah.
20:12.099 --> 20:15.670
I don't want my children to grow up and have
these kinds of problems,
20:15.739 --> 20:17.060
this kind of work.
20:17.869 --> 20:20.300
They should learn as much as possible.
20:20.790 --> 20:25.420
If only somebody would help us give them an
education, then we would support them,
20:25.949 --> 20:28.599
but with this work it is impossible for us.
20:29.469 --> 20:31.739
We wish for them to get a better education.
20:32.390 --> 20:34.819
We don't want them to end up in this job.
20:35.349 --> 20:39.260
If only they could study, they would do
something other than this.
20:39.910 --> 20:41.900
This work ends with me.
20:42.670 --> 20:44.459
I don't want them to do this.
20:46.979 --> 20:49.310
Yeah, I
20:54.430 --> 20:58.140
Kumar and the other stonemason families have
the afternoon off.
20:58.430 --> 21:01.670
They cannot work because of the nearby blasting
in the quarry.
21:04.250 --> 21:06.239
Oh yeah, all right.
21:15.010 --> 21:20.410
However, not all Dalits are prepared to go on
being treated as social and cultural outcasts
21:20.410 --> 21:24.739
in India.
In the summer of 1999, thousands of Dalit
21:24.739 --> 21:29.780
labourers from the tea plantations in the state
of Tamil Nadu mounted a demonstration for
21:29.780 --> 21:34.540
higher wages.
As in previous cases, the authorities' reaction
21:34.540 --> 21:35.579
was to clamp down.
21:39.219 --> 21:43.660
These pictures from the film Death of a River,
showing the laborers' demonstration, were
21:43.660 --> 21:46.699
screened 3 months later in a small cinema in
Madras.
21:47.550 --> 21:52.310
The film was subsequently seized by the police
and the owner of the cinema was arrested and
21:52.310 --> 21:56.810
imprisoned under Indian censorship laws
governing commercial feature films.
21:57.680 --> 22:00.239
Police brutality cost 18 lives.
22:11.199 --> 22:12.199
We are 19 families here and we stick together.
22:21.859 --> 22:25.969
We have no problems or disagreements.
22:27.619 --> 22:28.819
Some of us are related.
22:29.084 --> 22:31.415
But we are like one big family.
22:32.785 --> 22:34.295
We listen to each other.
22:35.104 --> 22:37.454
We also respect what the children say.
22:40.344 --> 22:44.015
We live in harmony with one another and respect
each other.
22:45.744 --> 22:46.765
We don't argue.
22:47.665 --> 22:50.474
Our extended family doesn't work like that.
22:53.064 --> 22:55.015
She's hiding samba, huh?
22:56.584 --> 22:57.824
Actually, this is not samba.
22:59.270 --> 23:04.099
If I work faster, I could make one month's pay
in 25 days.
23:04.349 --> 23:07.099
If I did, I could provide for my family.
23:10.109 --> 23:16.989
If I was paid ₹1500, I could pay the bills and
the hospital bill and still save money.
23:16.989 --> 23:20.885
For myself.
Build a mill, find a house, and make it suitable for
23:20.885 --> 23:22.515
weaving activities.
23:27.645 --> 23:28.994
There should be room for that.
23:29.285 --> 23:33.074
We could start out with one room; later, we could
buy another one.
23:33.324 --> 23:36.135
Then three, then four, and so forth.
23:39.800 --> 23:41.569
Yeah, yeah.
23:46.369 --> 23:49.439
In terms of rights, a washerman stands alone.
23:49.729 --> 23:54.069
There is only one washerman in each village.
If somebody supported me,
23:54.170 --> 23:57.660
we could fight for our rights, but there is
only me.
24:00.290 --> 24:01.530
I'm left in the lurch.
24:02.479 --> 24:08.270
If you want to achieve something, you have to
be either rich or be in a group of many people.
24:09.760 --> 24:10.800
I am neither.
24:16.369 --> 24:17.089
Was it up, up?
Distributor: Bullfrog Films
Length: 24 minutes
Date: 2000
Genre: Expository
Language: English
Grade: 7-12, College, Adult
Color/BW:
Closed Captioning: Available
Interactive Transcript: Available
Existing customers, please log in to view this film.
New to Docuseek? Register to request a quote.